It Doesn’t Have to Be This Way, You Know

May 12, 2010 at 8:10 pm | Posted in Garret Anderson, Hank Blalock, Tim Redding | 10 Comments

Apparently I’ve just got a thing with veteran lefty outfielders who wear #9, because I’ve done nothing but bash Garret Anderson all season long. It’s nothing personal, of course. He had a long and distinguished career with the Angels, but at some point you just have to admit it’s over. And when you’re featured in a block calling your your stats and praying for your release – seriously, just look at the numbers up there in the upper right – it’s over.

That said, my preferred replacement is Xavier Paul, who’s a far superior baserunner and defender who showed some nice offensive skill in his time in the bigs. While I don’t necessarily agree, there are those who say that he should be playing every day in AAA rather than part-time in MLB. Since I think he’d get plenty of time as Manny’s caddy and since I don’t think the Dodgers are really grooming him to be a starter anyway, it’s not something that concerns me.

Yet, if you do consider that a valid reason to keep Paul down, it’s not a zero-sum game. The choice is not simply between Anderson and Paul; there’s other options here, ones that could help the team immediately. Options like…

Hank Blalock. After not finding a job in the offseason, Blalock signed a minor-league deal with the Rays and has been crushing minor-league pitching: .366/.425/.535. If Blalock isn’t recalled by May 15th, he’s able to opt out and become a free agent, though there’s still a chance Tampa just eats what’s left on the $9m Pat Burrell’s owed this year to go with Blalock. If this sounds familiar to you, it’s because I said the Dodgers should have signed Blalock themselves back on April 2nd:

You can pick up Blalock – who’s still only 29, and whose top comparable at baseball-reference is actually Casey Blake – for absolutely nothing. Blalock’s got a lot working against him, I admit. But if you realize what he can do very well (crush righties), and don’t put him in the situations he’s terrible at (hitting lefties or wearing a glove) more than you absolutely have to, he can be a fantastically undervalued pickup for a team who desperately needs one. If that means having to cut ties with Nick Green, Garret Anderson, or Ronnie Belliard, then so be it.

And all Blalock’s done since then is prove that he can still hit, even surprisingly hitting lefties harder than righties with a crazy .522/.560/.870 line, though of course in a very small sample size of just 23 at-bats. There’s no question that he’s a far superior (and nine years younger!) player than Anderson right now, and he can even spell Casey Blake and James Loney at the corners, sparing you from having to see Ronnie Belliard there. Granted, this would leave you with only four outfielders, but since Matt Kemp and Andre Ethier play basically every day anyway, you could get by with just Reed Johnson. You can always toss Jamey Carroll out there in case of emergency, and Albuquerque’s just a few hours away.

If Blalock would cost more now than he would have six weeks ago, you can just consider that the cost of not making this move when it should have been done in the first place. Besides, no cost is too high to not have to watch Anderson and his osteoporosis out there any more, right? It’s known the Rays are looking for a right-handed reliever… I’m sure the Dodgers have a spare Ortiz to send.


Completely unrelated, but in case you’re hoping the Dodgers are going to go out and acquire a pitcher, just know that these are the types of guys they’re going to be in on:

Tim Redding agreed to a minor league deal with the Yankees, according to Troy Renck of the Denver Post (via Twitter). The Dodgers and multiple Korean teams also expressed interest in Redding, who was released by the Rockies this morning.

That would be the same Tim Redding who was just flat-out release from Colorado’s AAA affiliate after allowing 12.2 hits per 9 innings this year. Of course they were interested.

Be the first to like this post.


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. Wait….wasn’t Redding signed by the Yankees? So, crisis averted right?

    and speaking of Blalock. WTF? Super upgrade! I was behind this in april and am behind it now. Of course my opinion doesnt mean shit, but this seems like a no brainer.

  2. Nothing will be done this season that will cost extra money. No DFAs, no signing of potentially helpful players, and no trades unless it financially favors the Dodgers. This was proven out by keeping RO/GA over Ely/XP.

  3. I love this idea. I loved it when you first mentioned it way back.

  4. How exactly do Ely and Paul cost us any extra money, anteater?

    • I think the reasoning is that we paid RO/GA money to be on the team while Ely/XP are in the organization…if we DFA/release the first pair, it will have been “wasted” money.

  5. Flashback to spring training, the scene: an Arizona sports bar. A playful sports writer is chatting it up with a tipsy Joe Torre and Ned Colletti…

    Writer: “So what’s the deal with Garrett Anderson anyway?”
    Colletti: “Well I don’t see him really making the tea…”
    Writer: “Hundred bucks says you can’t keep Garret Anderson on the roster all season long.”
    Torre: “Oh yeaaa?? I’ll do you one better…200 says I not only keep him around, but actually give him at-bats in key situations”
    Writer: “You’re on, Joe, it’s a bet”

  6. What about Jay Gibbons. He’s been tearing it up in AAA hitting at an almost .400 clip. Why not bring him up? He can be the lefty bat off the bench and spell Manny every so often, while X Paul can stay in ALB and play everyday.

    • I’d actually made it halfway through including him in thie post… and then I checked his minor league splits and saw that he’s a HUGE creation of Albuquerque. His home road splits down there are insane.

  7. [...] not much help here. This is where I ought to throw in that it sure would have been great to have signed Hank Blalock rather than Garret Anderson, but that ship has clearly [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Blog at | Theme: Pool by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.