You’d Give Clayton Kershaw $30m Right Now, Right?

You all know that I think the season is all but over, and yesterday’s blowout at the hands of Atlanta only served as yet another nail in the coffin. If the Dodgers wanted to see what they could get for guys like Ted Lilly, Hiroki Kuroda, Octavio Dotel, and the other veterans I’d be more than okay with that right now. That being the case, I’ve been thinking a lot about the future, and not only the overwhelmingly negative parts of it (like, how do you fill holes at catcher, second base, third base, left field, and 3/5 of the starting rotation with no money and few prospects?)

More specifically, I’m talking about the future of Clayton Kershaw, who at just 22 has lived up to the hype that accompanied his arrival. For the second year in a row, he’s in the top ten in the NL in most strikeouts per nine and fewest hits allowed per nine. He’s dramatically improved his control (walks/nine dropping from 4.8 to 3.8), he’s working deeper into games, and of his 24 starts this year, he’s allowed three earned runs or less in 20 of them. He’s awesome, he’s getting better, and he won’t even be 23 until spring training - a rare bright spot in what is quickly becoming a spiraling season.

I’m bringing this topic up now because the Blue Jays just signed their own young lefty, Ricky Romero, to a five-year deal, and it’s time to start thinking about doing the same for Kershaw. Romero and Kershaw are similar in many ways, each being lefty top-10 draft picks in their second full seasons, and MLBTR notes that Romero’s deal also bears similarities to deals that Jon Lester and Yovani Gallardo recently signed. At the time of the deals, all three had one more season left before arbitration, and at the end of the year, Kershaw will have 2 years and 105 days of MLB service, meaning he’ll probably fall just short of qualifying for “Super Two” status and arbitration eligibility.

All three signed deals for $30m over five years. Are those fair comparables for Kershaw? Let’s find out. Lester signed his before 2009, and Gallardo before 2010; I’ll use their stats at the time of the deal.


It’s not a perfect comparison, as Kershaw is younger than all three, yet will have far more starts under his belt by the end of the year than any had at the time of their deals. But the stats are similar, and nothing on that chart matters more than the nearly identical amount of service time, because that’s how these deals get made. The difference in value between a pre-arbitration year, the three arbitration years, and free agency years are astronomical, and when the time comes to make this deal happen, both sides will be looking at players in similar situations. The last remaining pre-arbitration year is really the big deal here; look at Zack Greinke and Josh Johnson, who each recently signed similar four-year deals, for $38m (Greinke) and $39m (Johnson). The average per-year salary on those two deals (north of $9m/year) were higher than any of our three comparables, but Greinke and Johnson each had more leverage because they had exhausted their pre-arbitration years and were poised to get huge raises in arbitration.

FanGraphs breaks down the difference between going yearly or signing long-term, and you can really replace Romero’s name with Kershaw in this quote, because the details are identical – even down to the 3.4 WAR produced in 2010.

Romero will finish his second year of service time in 2010 and would have been on a club-controlled contract for 2011. He would then be arbitration eligible for 2012, ’13 and ’14 and a free agent or 2015. Given the standard guide of 40%/60%/80% of market value expected for arbitration rulings, the five years of Romero’s contract add up to 2.8 seasons of free market worth plus one year at the league minimum. That is what Toronto and Romero are surrendering by not going year-to-year.

With a payment of $30.1 million guaranteed, that works out to the Jays paying Romero $10.75 million per market year. With current trends pegging the market dollars paid per win at around $4 million we have an estimation of about 2.75 to 3.0 wins per season for the contract’s middle point once we factor in the discount Romero should be offering for the security of a long-term deal.

Romero produced 2.7 WAR last season and is already at 3.4 this year so on the face of it, this looks like a possible win for the Blue Jays already.

They liked the Gallardo deal as well, noting that ”the new contract represents good value for the Brewers while providing ample personal security,” so unless you think Kershaw’s about to fall off a cliff, this is a sensible idea for the Dodgers, especially since he had the most WAR of the three in 2009 (4.2 to Gallardo’s 3.4 and Romero’s 2.7.)

So $30m over 5 years seems to be the going rate for this caliber of pitcher at this point in his career, and if you want to toss in a bit more because Kershaw is younger, that’d be fine by me too. If nothing is done, he’ll make less than a million dollars in 2011. That’s a steal. But then he’ll be eligible for arbitration, and if he keeps on his current career path the yearly arbitration raises are going to get expensive and unpredictable. What if 2011 is his true breakout year, where he goes 21-6 with 212 K? We’ll be begging for the days when he might have been had for only $6m/year. So while I’m sure the responses here are going to be “sure, but the Dodgers are poor” (and it’s not that you’re wrong, it’s just that I’m trying to pretend we’re fans of a real baseball team for once), this is a deal that would save the Dodgers money in the long run.

Besides, if smaller teams like Toronto and Milwaukee can do it… there’s no reason the Dodgers shouldn’t be able to as well. This has the potential to be a painful offseason for a variety of reasons, and a commitment made to one of the game’s bright young stars would go a long way towards easing that.

******

Don’t forget, tonight at 9pm PST is the deadline for the Dodgers to sign 1st-round pick Zach Lee. Unconfirmed reports are saying that they’ll offer him $3m to forget his LSU commitment and start his professional career. If that offer is accurate – and like you, I’ll believe it when I see it – whether or not he takes it is almost irrelevant, because that would be an offer higher than the Royals gave the #4 pick, Christian Colon. Should the offer be made and verified, then a lot of us may have a whole lot of crow to eat for our post-draft reactions.

0 comments

Trackbacks

  1. [...] down at the time, so I couldn’t put anything up. He’s, uh, good at baseball. Remember when I said last month you absolutely have to get him signed long-term this offseason? That goes double [...]

  2. [...] you can even still get him that cheaply. I’d go into this in greater detail, except I already did just that in August. Basically, based on recent deals signed by comparable pitchers like Ricky Romero, Yovani Gallardo, [...]

  3. [...] they do, and one who still has room to improve thanks to his youth. It’s why I’ve put signing him to a long-term deal while the price is still reasonable high on my offseason to-do [...]

  4. [...] I’ll be the first to say that this hasn’t exactly been the brightest offseason around here. We’ve been dismayed at the seemingly excessive contracts handed out to Matt Guerrier, Rod Barajas, and Juan Uribe. We’ve cringed at the impending disastrophe of the JaMarcus Gwybbons, Jr. situation in left field, wondered why they couldn’t find a righty partner for Andre Ethier, been disappointed over the inability to upgrade on Casey Blake, and resigned ourselves to another year of mediocrity from James Loney. We’ve been terrified at how there’s both no good option for a #2 hitter and how the lineup as a whole seems to have been assembled with no regard for OBP. We’ve worried about atrocious outfield defense and considered what things may have looked like if the near-misses for aging vets Aubrey Huff , Michael Young, and A.J. Pierzynski hadn’t been misses at all. We’ve fretted that minor-league deals or not, historically poor players like Juan Castro and Aaron Miles are in the mix and just may make the team, and we’ve wondered when and if proven young talents like Clayton Kershaw and Chad Billingsley would see long-term deals.  [...]

  5. [...] Of course, the reason that I was even listing reasons for optimism at the point in the winter is that we’d suffered through such a long, depressing winter. Here’s how I prefaced that February article: I’ll be the first to say that this hasn’t exactly been the brightest offseason around here. We’ve been dismayed at the seemingly excessive contracts handed out to Matt Guerrier, Rod Barajas, and Juan Uribe. We’ve cringed at the impending disastrophe of the JaMarcus Gwybbons, Jr. situation in left field, wondered why they couldn’t find a righty partner for Andre Ethier, been disappointed over the inability to upgrade on Casey Blake, and resigned ourselves to another year of mediocrity from James Loney. We’ve been terrified at both how there’s no good option for a #2 hitter and how the lineup as a whole seems to have been assembled with no regard for OBP. We’ve worried about atrocious outfield defense and considered what things may have looked like if the near-misses for aging vets Aubrey Huff , Michael Young, and A.J. Pierzynski hadn’t been misses at all. We’ve fretted that minor-league deals or not, historically poor players like Juan Castro and Aaron Miles are in the mix and just may make the team, and we’ve wondered when and if proven young talents like Clayton Kershaw and Chad Billingsley would see long-term deals. [...]

  6. [...] how much might the Dodgers have cost themselves by not locking up Kershaw before his breakout year? We looked at just that topic in August of 2010, comparing Kershaw’s situation to other young pitchers with similar service time who had [...]

  7. [...] Got that? Good. Now let’s recall how we felt about the 2010-11 offseason back in Februrary: I’ll be the first to say that this hasn’t exactly been the brightest offseason around here. We’ve been dismayed at the seemingly excessive contracts handed out to Matt Guerrier, Rod Barajas, and Juan Uribe. We’ve cringed at the impending disastrophe of the JaMarcus Gwybbons, Jr. situation in left field, wondered why they couldn’t find a righty partner for Andre Ethier, been disappointed over the inability to upgrade on Casey Blake, and resigned ourselves to another year of mediocrity from James Loney. We’ve been terrified at both how there’s no good option for a #2 hitter and how the lineup as a whole seems to have been assembled with no regard for OBP. We’ve worried about atrocious outfield defense and considered what things may have looked like if the near-misses for aging vets Aubrey Huff , Michael Young, and AJ Pierzynski hadn’t been misses at all. We’ve fretted that minor-league deals or not, historically poor players like Juan Castro and Aaron Miles are in the mix and just may make the team, and we’ve wondered when and if proven young talents like Clayton Kershaw and Chad Billingsley would see long-term deals. [...]

  8. [...] Kershaw’s eligible for free agency following the 2014 season, so this doesn’t completely buy out his arbitration years. That’s fine, but it’s also the route the Phillies have taken with Cole Hamels, and they’re set up for a difficult situation as he enters his walk year with no long-term contract in place. Obviously, the Dodgers are in a different situation – they have just one other large deal as opposed to several, and the ownership situation hangs over everything at the moment – but it’s clear that whomever is actually in control of the club going forward needs to spend every moment of the two years this deal covers attempting to sign Kershaw to the long-term contract we’ve wanted him to have for quite some time. [...]

  9. then that is what people will remember,…

    and it will reflect well on you. a great way to make yourself, your products and your websites known is through article writing. marketing on the internet can be very costly, especially when you are trying to reach a particular kind…

  10. putting up their links on your blogs….

    blogging and make money blogging are easy when you know what to do. blogging is easy and when you have a blog you have the added opportunity to make money through the platform of your blog. blogging is easy for those…

  11. franchises says:

    only way. as a whole, you can…

    offer a single image or layout throughout your entire blog, allowing your writing to take center stage to any pictures on your blog posting.the next method of generating a hardcore blog is to set yourself apart through your writing. create something…

  12. who is hard working. – someone who…

    is on a budget. – someone who might be discouraged. – someone who already has a blog set up.these are just a few examples of the kind of person that might type in those keywords. now i will formulate a sentence…

  13. writing as a minimum about 3 blog…

    posts a week. you should also make sure they are full of good content, are of value to the reader and complement your business. this is very important as when people arrive at your blog they want to know what they…

  14. want them to do? here are a…

    few things to keep in mind:- sum up the key message from the post. – encourage your reader to take action. – ask your reader to share and/or tweet your post. – let your reader know what’s coming up next and…

  15. website says:

    and diction. also of importance to college…

    essay writing is the ability to access source material and quote it properly using mla documentation.taking an english composition course will not only assist you in your college endeavors but will also help you in whatever career you choose. writing s…

  16. only, you will find that it will…

    take a longer time to monetize as opposed to paying for the traffic.now there are all kinds of ways to make money with your opt-in email list. one of the best things that you can do is to build trust. building…

  17. click here says:

    right amount of keywords. i know you…

    would want your blog posts to rank really well on relevant search page results but loading them with too many keywords will not help you achieve that. to make your posts search engine and reader-friendly, ensure that you do not use…

  18. solve a problem. they provide useful and…

    informative information that provides great value to the reader. blog post writing will get easier when you learn how to leverage these pillar articles. every day millions of people are searching for information online. as a blogger, this can be very…

  19. a good articles. write when you have…

    free time, maybe when you come home from work or are felling well enough to write an article usually there is a time of day when you just feel like writing choose then to write.7. do your research, the internet is…

  20. services have finally come out of the…

    closet, it does not mean that everyone is providing quality content. there are certain companies, though, they are providing affordable content writing services, fail to provide quality content for your website. which can in the long run prove to be di…

  21. stuff ‘em in there!” don’t, seriously. search…

    engines run algorithms that find blogs that pack posts with keywords and punish them. i am not saying use few keywords. confusing? okay, here’s what you do: use the keyword around three times in your opening paragraph and maybe twice in…

  22. buy birkin says:

    and amazon does the rest. you can…

    sign up as an amazon affiliate using the link at the bottom of the amazon home page titled “become an affiliate”. there is no cost to join amazon affiliates.you then grab the html code supplied by amazon and put that onto…

  23. of creativity can go a long way…

    in popularizing your blog.following are a few tips for creating a great blog article that will attract internet traffic.great, innovative contentof course good quality blog content is the first and foremost characteristic of a popular blog. and the con…

  24. 500, then your readers will be very…

    happy people. a common misconception is that the more words you write, the better you will do, but in fact, if you can be concise and yet still informative, you are going to have far more success with your content than…

  25. attention organize your thoughts into relevant points…

    and then focus on one point at a time. one thing that is imperative to the success of your blog is giving authentic information on your site. you have to make sure that every piece of information that you put on…

  26. click here says:

    do anything. a lot of blogs come…

    to fame from mentions on other larger blogs or by word of mouth. if you have a lot of good content people won’t be afraid of mentioning you to their friends.a great way to build a rep as a good writer…

  27. svubit says:

    her family’s doorstep one day with a…

    gigantic present for her. her curiosity over why her parents never told her about this mysterious uncle was only superseded by what could be in the box that was as large as her. when it turned out to be a baby…

  28. visit us says:

    are called backlinks and it is a…

    main factor in how search engines rank sites and return results for keyword search terms.this is the essence and basics of online writing, why it is a legitimate and profitable job, and why original content is in such high demand.so how…

  29. the next few years.know your subject -…

    if you are writing about a specific subject and you are basically guessing your way through it and trying to make the article sound thorough, then your readers are going to read straight through it. if you are writing about a…

  30. tablet says:

    about but the link needn’t be direct…

    and ideally should not be self-serving.please note that this approach is different from something like article marketing, which is covered later. writing about other businesses and organizations on your own web site still generates traffic to your web …

  31. valuable – use your imagination! among the…

    excellent things about internet marketing are the possibilities it has made available to earn money with various work at home opportunities. other online business owners will pay individuals to do things for them which includes many forms of writing. i…

  32. Titanic says:

    proficiency levels of the writers by giving…

    sample tests before handing over a project. it is important to do enough Titanic research and make consultations before hiring a specific content writing company. ensure that you have a look at their work portfolio to see the level of quality they…

  33. Macbook says:

    obvious imagery, try finding an image which…

    reflects an analogy or story within your post, or perhaps a facial expression or image of someone engaged in an activity related to the topic. if you think about it, there’s usually something which fits…choose a bold and bright picture (especially…

  34. back to go to the third world…

    for cheap articles but many of these were low quality and demanded editing before they were suitable to use. freelance writing customers don’t want this, why would you pay for an article that you have to waste time editing? the whole…

  35. you can gain just four or five…

    loyal readers each day, it won’t be long before word of mouth grows your following all by itself. you must also write content that people yearn to read. Titanic i know that there are two or three blogs that i can’t wait…

  36. car stereo says:

    can either create your own short video…

    or get the html code and embed it into your post. you tube is a great resource for this, but always make sure that you write a short summary about your impressions on the video.cause and effectthis is a fun way…

  37. should create visual distinction between your article…

    and the rest of the page. write an introductory paragraph for each blog post. an illuminated screen slows reading by up to 30%. to increase readability, create short paragraphs and avoid large blocks of text.make your font size readable. studies have…

  38. does not ensure that it is going…

    to get visited. by avoiding the top mistakes in blog promotion you will have a blog that is actively read and visited by many web users. below we are going to list some of the most common reasons why your blog…

  39. high quality, relevant content.the most difficult part…

    will be learning to write in a manner that will captivate your readers. when it comes to your site, it is not enough to frequently publish fresh content. that content needs to be well written and to target exactly the group…

  40. remix artist says:

    do about it.before you start blogging, there…

    are some things you need to know about it and some best practices for you to follow to ensure you are maximizing your time and your efforts.first, in order for your efforts to be worth your time, you must blog on…

  41. cite surprising statistics. we all love statistics….

    you can easily do a google search for statistics, but make sure they are credible. when you provide statistics, it gives your blog post more flavor. it shows that you have spent more time and energy on the blog and that…

  42. Nicki Minaj says:

    they just take about 5 to 10…

    minutes to write.google is searching for longer articles of 500 words or longer. due to the fact many bloggers are not willing to sit down and create these longer articles this provides you an opportunity to be there for them. you…

  43. Airsoft says:

    Evike.com…

    Evike.com is your own stop shop for all things Airsoft. Here, you can buy Airsoft magazines and Airsoft ammo….

  44. [...] about this kind of record-setting investment certainly makes the conversations we had two-and-a-half years ago about giving him 5/$30m seem quaint now, doesn’t it? From that piece, which makes me want to punch myself in the face [...]