Gaining Clarity on the Dodger Batting Order

About six weeks ago, I examined the Dodger batting order, wondering how this oddly assembled mismash of players would fit behind Rafael Furcal at the top. I reviewed some options, but basically determined that there was no perfect solution, particularly at #2.

Over the weekend, a story from Ken Gurnick of dodgers.com has helped us gain a little bit of insight into what Don Mattingly is thinking:

One day before he addresses the full squad for the first time as manager, Don Mattingly said Monday he plans to bat Ethier third and Kemp fourth and keep them there “all year long.”

Mattingly said he’s still thinking about Casey Blake as a No. 2 hitter behind leadoff hitter Rafael Furcal. That would likely mean James Loney following Kemp, with Uribe sixth, the left-field platoon of Marcus Thames/Jay Gibbons seventh and the catching platoon of Rod Barajas/Dioner Navarro eighth.

Ethier at 3 and Kemp at 4 is what I predicted in January, and it could be awesome, or it could just as easily be disastrous. Nonetheless, it’s an acceptable use of imperfect options, because we’ve known all winter that the success of the 2011 largely hinges on what you get out of those two. JaMarcus Gwybbons, Jr., at 7 and the catchers at 8 is also the best you can do with those subpar choices, so that’s fine as well. Loney at 5 and Uribe at 6 seems to also make sense, continuing the L/R balance of the lineup and pushing Uribe’s inferior OBP down as far as you can; ideally, he’ll often come up with some combination of Ethier, Kemp, and Loney on base, allowing his occasional power to do the most damage.

That brings us to the only really questionable idea, which is putting Casey Blake in the two spot. I certainly understand Mattingly’s thinking there, because it does make for a great L/R lineup balance (on days that Gibbons or Gwynn starts at #7, there wouldn’t be a single situation with back-to-back hitters from the same side), and there’s quite honestly no obvious solution. The problem, of course, is that Blake is hardly the ideal answer himself. At 37, he’s coming off what is arguably the worst year of his career; his 27.1 whiff percentage is the highest he’s ever had, and his .159 ISO is the lowest he’s had since 2002. He’s making less contact, he’s hitting for less power, and his age doesn’t exactly promise a rebound. It’s not really the kind of hitter you want to see getting the second-most at-bats in your lineup, or the kind of guy who gives you hope that he can advance Furcal into scoring position for Ethier and Kemp to take advantage of.

Still, I’m hard-pressed to offer a better solution. Uribe’s brand of low OBP and decent power certainly doesn’t fit the spot any better, though I do wonder if James Loney may be an interesting choice there. We all know that Loney has little power, though his K rate was 10% less than Blake’s. On the other hand, that could certainly turn into more double plays, given Loney’s propensity for hitting grounders nearly half the time. I guess the tiebreaker here is that it would also mess with the L/R split, because you’d have lefties at 2 and 3, and righties at 4-5-6 (assuming it’d be Kemp-Blake-Uribe).

So I suppose it comes down to this: I don’t like Casey Blake as a #2 hitter, but there’s also not a really great alternative. So I tentatively approve of Mattingly’s choices here, since he’s doing the best with the limited options he’s been handed.

******

In other news, we have our first injury note of the spring (and yes, I saw that Dana Eveland pulled his hamstring last week, and no, that doesn’t count):

Vicente Padilla is heading to LA to have MRI on his right elbow, which has similar pains as last year. Results expected tomorrow.

That’s not a great sign, though it does underscore the importance of all of the pitching depth Ned Colletti put together this offseason. If anything, it might scuttle any prospective battle between Padilla and Jon Garland for the #5 spot, since it sounds like Padilla’s injury concerns might make him more effectively used in short bursts anyway.

0 comments

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Mike Scioscia’s Tragic Disease, we get a glimpse of what Don Mattingly is thinking in terms of the Dodgers lineup: Mattingly said [...]

  2. [...] Casey Blake 2nd, saying that one of the reasons is that he can bunt. I said last week that while I wasn’t thrilled with hitting Blake 2nd, I also didn’t have any obviously better solutions, but bunting is [...]

  3. decide on the best job description in…

    order to target the best candidates. rather than posting boring and long descriptions of the responsibilities, only mention the essential qualifications and duties to keep it simple and short. clearly state that the listed requirements have to be met t…

  4. if they have mastered the mechanics of…

    how to be a good writer. this is mainly because good writing comes from experience. experiences fuel the creative thought process behind someone’s writing and they drive the creation of new written material.as you begin your process to becoming a bett…

  5. interesting data. this could be expert advice,…

    answer to burning question, a guide on how to solve a specific issue, and trade secrets.5. keep it short. remember, you’re writing for online users who are known to have a very short attention span. so, don’t even try to make…

  6. click here says:

    for greater length. like penzu it offers…

    quite a variety of themes for more of a personalized site.two more very similar tools that are easy to use in creation of your website are joomla and drupal. both remain quite alike in their features and functions, drupal however remains…

  7. never be promotional or advertising but informative;…

    and • article directories won’t accept advertising contents.selection of best provider some of the factors that will determine the selection of the best article writing services for high standard articles for seo as follows. • they should me…

  8. franchises says:

    these people will have something valuable to…

    offer in terms of advice or even just in sharing their stories. forums like this can help you make business connections, so it’s a good idea to have a good online presence.consider joining an online forum as a means of increasing…

  9. this says:

    descriptions are important as they often appear…

    as a snippet just beneath the title in the search engine results.a well written meta description can increase click-through-rate. google is more likely to show your meta description as the snippet if it contains all of the keywords from the user’s…

  10. my website says:

    try too hard to be elaborate and…

    they overdo it. always strive to use simple words and to choose the word that will mean the most to your readers. if you use a word you found in the dictionary or thesaurus but did not know the meaning of…

  11. make sure you are satisfied with the…

    writing before you pay the rest of the bill.the next time you are looking for a good writing service, you need to use these three tips when choosing seo content writers. there are companies that charge more, but you are getting…

  12. would be an excellent ‘preview’ to what…

    readers can expect on your platform! readers can get a feel for your writing ability and then simply follow the link if what you wrote did indeed stir an interest! not only that but your articles are often a great source…

  13. alternative route if at all possible. by…

    some miracle i found a d-mannose web site along with some very interesting blogs of people who use d-mannose and had complete success. i had my prescription, but i wanted to try d-mannose which is a natural sugar found in certain…

  14. visit site says:

    site visitors more of what attracted them…

    in the first place in terms of information! the platform you have needs to maintain relevancy to the theme it represents therefore keep your posts focused upon subject matter that does so! drifting away from the theme of the site when…

  15. into one post. your window of opportunity…

    is often narrow – people have short attentions spans – so keep your blog content to the point. and make it a good point.• make it easy to share. people will hit the ‘share’ button without a moments hesitation if it…

  16. then it will make them feel like…

    you have something in common and they will want to read your blog all the time. you can also participate in question and answer sites and this will attract attention too. you can also encourage subscribers by e-mail opt-in. send them…

  17. in your niche and ask them if…

    they are interested in having a guest post from you. if they e-mail you back then they are most likely interested. keep in mind that not everyone will e-mail you back. you will get direct traffic to your blog by putting…

  18. more info says:

    well millions of people who have put…

    solutions to these problems on the internet and among the people who put the solutions on the internet is you. now, how can you make sure that your answer in the form of a blog post get read and action is…

  19. them onto your blog as posts. as…

    long as they have an rss feed of course. great for news type of blogs. use this alongside your own content then you have a winning combination. regular posting of content is good in the eyes of search engines, they don’t…

  20. Click! says:

    of time because they still only have…

    a small group following them and never get any interactions. the problem isn’t with facebook. the problem is with you not understanding how to use it. here are a few things i have learned.if you own a business, facebook needs to…

  21. religiously, coupled with effective seo and a…

    bit of creativity can go a long way in popularizing your blog.following are a few tips for creating a great blog article that will attract internet traffic.great, innovative contentof course good quality blog content is the first and foremost character…

  22. have this quality.ebook writers are hard to…

    find. only the best web content writers have competent skills to write ebooks. for instance, ebooks must have the latest information and they must be written to capture the attention of the reader. moreover, because ebooks are digital in format, they…

  23. you want you need to remember that…

    not every computer has every font installed on it. in particular, most people don’t have the fancy fonts installed on their machines. so if you choose one of these fonts for your blog it will not display how you want it…

  24. posts and see if you can write…

    something about the same thing. offer your own insights on what they are writing about and you should have some good content.the other thing about having good content is that your blog will spread around the web without you having to…

  25. who their audiences are. misunderstanding the audience…

    simply means that the topic is right but you do not connect with the audience. as a blogger, it is wise to understand the problems that your audiences are facing so that you may convey helpful information that will solve their…

  26. the nature of the blog, business owners…

    may even choose to include their own personal opinions about different subjects or stray off-topic from time to time in order to seem more personable. no one understands the process of writing a successful blog better than blog post writers for…

  27. high school. you’ll better understand what your…

    instructor is talking about if you know the basic terms used when talking about grammar and sentence structure.be ready to grow as a writer, which includes moving beyond the more structured writing you did in high school. in your college papers,…

  28. ipad says:

    a rarer skill.there are several different types…

    of essays: formal or informal, personal or impersonal. subject matter can range from personal experiences to literary criticism to analysis of current news events. an essay can compare similarities and differences between two or more books, movies, or …

  29. Titanic says:

    correspondence. give this to your scholar friends,…

    or to friends in high-powered jobs in the corporate industry.4. calligraphy pen ink and setsyour alternative gifts set will be complete if you get Titanic matching calligraphy pen ink and sets. calligraphy writing techniques deserve the best writing ma…

  30. probably wouldn’t be able to tell any…

    difference.really, the thing that most people remember is the quality of the article, how helpful it was to them, and how easy it was to read. if all the articles that are submitted under your name are that type of article,…

  31. progression by playing these games which are…

    productive as well as fun.the higher the number of blog posts you are able to publish, the more response you will receive. this needs precise detailing within a short span of time. if you are a fast typer with good writing…

  32. Mac väska says:

    you outsource the writing tasks to offshore…

    workers?most website owners, or the people requiring the write ups for any other reasons, are usually busy people. so it is not likely that they can get time to sit down and write the information peacefully and cool-headedly. besides, there are…

  33. focused, by presenting less arguments. this gives…

    more room for each thought, making it is easier for the reader to notice and remember the main Titanic ideas in your writings.5. don’t try to get things too perfect – allow your skills to grow. you don’t have to be a…

  34. Installation says:

    up with the best blog title possible….

    you’ll see that it’s fun, and you’ll improve your reading style. all bloggers go through a time when they don’t know what to post next. it can be very frustrating and in all of this, our blogs suffer due to neglect….

  35. new things such as failure and defeat…

    for you to be able to accept that there are things that you need to do perfect your skills.find a writer’s group near you and join them. this group will consist of writers who have experience over the years and have…

  36. envoy says:

    stream has people from all over the…

    globe starting up blogs to try to make some quick money.sadly, making money with a blog isn’t as easy as it is made to sound. it’s not difficult at all to sign up with blogger, and start a free blog -…

  37. post topic. when promoting a particular product…

    or niche, be sure to mention that at the beginning of the blog post to get the reader interested in the topic. blog posts are typically not as long in length as regular articles, so anywhere from 200-400 words is acceptable.it…

  38. packs. this way you can sell one…

    pack to many people. you should sell only to people who don’t need unique articles.internet marketerdo you want to learn how online marketing works? do you have any negotiation skills? then become an internet marketer, and promote website for payment….

  39. times resources of the individual that person…

    has a much greater chance of developing a successful blog!here are 3 reasons why every blogger should write content at a pace that is most comfortable for them!better contentchoosing your own pace puts less pressure on you which also means it…

  40. Rebecca says:

    a tall big boned woman might require…

    significantly more calories.dieting after having a baby requires the dieter to consider her unique situation. if she is breast feeding, she needs to consume more calories than she needs for herself; she needs to have enough energy to produce her baby’…

  41. Airsoft says:

    Evike.com…

    Looking to accessorize your Airsoft experience? Evike.com has you covered, visit us today to discover a vast range in Airsoft….