Is Jay Gibbons The Best Use of a Roster Spot?


Me, yesterday:

Of the nine left fielders from last year, only Jay Gibbons seems certain to see time there again this year, and even still I’ve been spending half the spring wondering if he’s going to lose his roster spot.

Let’s make it more than half the spring now, because the more his spring struggles continue while others make their case, the more I wonder how much we should be looking to use that roster spot somewhere else. Gibbons entered today hitting .114/.162/.114, and an after an 0-3 with 2 K, that’s down to .105/.150/.105, by my rough calculations (MLB.com spring stats haven’t included today’s games yet, hence the estimating). The usual caveats about the importance of spring stats apply, of course, but someone with Gibbons’ history of missed time and winter ball struggles can’t really afford to have such a poor camp. (And by “poor camp”, I mean that over 200 MLB players have as many PA as he does, and every last one has more than the four total bases he’s picked up. Four!)

That’s on top of the fact that Gibbons hasn’t really been a quality big league player in about five years and had just a .313 OBP in what was seen as a “big splash” late last season, and you start to wonder how much of his seemingly guaranteed roster spot is due to his status as a hometown feel-good story.

Worse for Gibbons, the players behind him are making their case. I mentioned how well Tony Gwynn has played this spring a few days ago, and Xavier Paul has shaken off a slow start to become one of the hotter hitters in camp of late, including making a nice diving catch in today’s game. Then there’s camp sensation Hector Gimenez, who despite an oh-fer today, threw out a runner at the plate in his first left field appearance. Paul and Gimenez, as you surely remember, are each out of options.

Gwynn, Paul, and Gimenez all hit from the left side (Gimenez being a switch-hitter). Gwynn & Paul are both far superior defensive outfielders and baserunners to Gibbons, and while Gimenez probably isn’t, he offers the flexibility of being able to catch and play 1B. Besides, James Loney hits lefty as well, making Gibbons less necessary at first base and somewhat of an awkward fit for this roster as constructed.

So I have to ask: isn’t it time we seriously consider an Opening Day roster that doesn’t include Jay Gibbons? Gibbons hasn’t done much to earn it, and while I’m not going to pretend that I really care about Gimenez enough to say that you can’t chance losing him to keep Gibbons, I do feel that way about Paul.

Besides, that wouldn’t have to be the end of Gibbons; I hope it’s not, really, because I do like him. But hitting the way he is, I’d be surprised if anyone else wanted to give him a major league job, and he’d almost certainly end up back in Albuquerque. So let him try to rake down there for a few weeks, change “JaMarcus Gwybbons, Jr.” to, I don’t know, “Marcony X. Paul, Jr.”, and if Gibbons is hitting well in AAA in May, see how the rest of the roster has shaken out by that point.

Better that, than losing Paul for a player who’s not demonstrably better, right?

0 comments

Trackbacks

  1. [...] break camp on the team. There’s Jay Gibbons, whose spot may or may not really be in danger, despite my concerns. There’s even Jamie Hoffman, who’s lost his spot before, though I think that’s [...]

  2. [...] for Xavier Paul. There’s no way you can keep six outfielders on the roster for long, and as I said recently, I prefer Paul to Gibbons. That said, small sample sizes be damned: if Paul gets off to a 1-for-10 [...]

  3. [...] problems. From a pure baseball perspective, this doesn’t bother me all that much; after all, I did argue just last week that he wasn’t worth a roster spot, and this does almost guarantee that Xavier Paul makes the [...]

  4. tasks.however, you will find that the writers…

    around you will ask you for such a high price that, most of the time, you either keep the writings pending or you simply do a rough write up which definitely is not going to be interesting for your audience. the…

  5. site says:

    direction. your readers will come to respect…

    you and will become loyal to you before you know it.conclusioncontent creation is so much more than blogging. while blogging is extremely important and is a very effective online tool in your armamentarium, it is not the only important and effective…

  6. a plan, well if you can think…

    of a plan then that is great, do it, i have at times, however, what i tend to do is start writing. why? well it gets things down on paper (or screen) it is easier to edit stuff that is written…

  7. franchises says:

    methods in which they are finding information…

    just like yours. you ignore keyword research at your own risk. many hate the process because they feel too “hemmed in” by the way they can write their articles when in reality it allows them to be more focused in the…

  8. company says:

    any case the writer can make good…

    only by following the guidelines issues. resources that are used by the companies for prospective as well as existing members include -• article writing guidelines; • general guidelines for writing articles; • editorial guidelines; and …

  9. website says:

    terms & conditions that the authors name…

    and link must stay visible when the article is placed onto other sites, which is good for you; not only does it give you google friendly backlinks, but it can be seen by many more eyes. to get people wanting to…

  10. to the needs of our society? and…

    if not, what is hindering the growth of these important skills?college professors require students to be good writers. they expect decently written papers and a writing style that the student has developed through much attention. this is regardless of …

  11. bad. from your readers point of view,…

    there is nothing worse than reading content that is littered with spelling errors or badly structured content, so make sure you write well, check and then double check to make sure that content is a good as it can be.know your…

  12. might not want to read till the…

    end if useless information is shared in the beginning. there should not be fancy words used instead the post should be in a simple, easy to understand language.one thing that makes a post interesting is its uniqueness so try to be…

  13. of them, but a good majority, paid…

    and unpaid.of all the traffic methods i have used, past and present, one of the best ways to attract more visitors and, in turn readers, is to get involved with the community you are targeting.let me say it again – get…

  14. left with no choice but to write…

    about that certain topic. now the problem in this scenario is the tendency of a writer to poorly perform or refuse to write due to his lack of interest in the assigned topic. what should be done? be flexible like how…

  15. Click! says:

    time will come. the important thing for…

    you to do is to keep cooking every minute of the day. you can’t ever taste the warmth and flavor of success without first putting in the time necessary to get the ingredients right and allow them to cook until finished….

  16. amount of readers, and have a substantial…

    amount of quality posts, you will want to apply for a google adsense account. because google now directly owns blogger, this step could not be easier. you can apply for an adsense account directly from the blogger interface. considering the amount…

  17. people expect to get good information from…

    someone who really knows the subject. if you are more salesy, people can like that as well. lots of people like visiting blogs that are strictly reviewing things that they are considering buying. think about angie’s list for a minute. that…

  18. red birkin says:

    other online videos is free. if you…

    choose to insert a video from youtube, click the “from url” tab, and paste the link of the youtube video then select insert into post.the moment that you are happy with the set up of your blog and editing its contents,…

  19. make money by writing to others.you can…

    also write an ebook about a topic you know about a lot. it’s a great way to make passive income. however, for this method you should learn how to market online.another option you have as an online writer is creating article…

  20. do anything. a lot of blogs come…

    to fame from mentions on other larger blogs or by word of mouth. if you have a lot of good content people won’t be afraid of mentioning you to their friends.a great way to build a rep as a good writer…

  21. to write those posts for you. your…

    readers will be happier for it.• fresher writing stylethe third reason you should outsource some or all of your writing tasks is that it will give your blog a fresher writing style. the popularity of multiple-author blogs confirms the fact that…

  22. another important thing which many webmasters do…

    not do. once you have your comment approved on a blogs, bookmark that blog with the top social bookmarking sites like dig, stumble upon and delicious. this provides two benefits. one your links get indexed fast. secondly the blog gets valuable…

  23. if a video that you upload to…

    youtube is around 100mb big… it’s going to take a long time for that 1 video to upload. and by the time you’ve finished uploading all of your videos, you will have to wait in the same way while you submit…

  24. tablet says:

    have to do is write articles on…

    your topic and then submit them to publishers.of course the effectiveness of any article marketing campaign is dependent on your ability to write articles consistently. a lot of people put off starting an article marketing campaign because they’re afr…

  25. Titanic says:

    of the many blog writing jobs or…

    article writing jobs that fits your style. why write about something you know little about and care even less about? if you are trying to earn a living or supplement your existing income, why not enjoy yourself while Titanic you are at…

  26. same. after all, your website is nothing…

    short of a virtual storefront! so, you need to ensure that your writer also understands the need to make a great first impression on your website visitors, and thus, is motivated to create original, reader-friendly, seo content that showcases your busi…

  27. Mac väska says:

    a tall big boned woman might require…

    significantly more calories.dieting after having a baby requires the dieter to consider her unique situation. if she is breast feeding, she needs to consume more calories than she needs for herself; she needs to have enough energy to produce her baby’…

  28. broad range of mediums in order to…

    connect effectively with potential Titanic employees. some combine newspaper classifieds, vacancy postings on the company website, job board listings, and employee referrals. meanwhile, there are also those that choose to focus on one particular avenue…

  29. Installation says:

    a lot of quality work in so…

    do quality work for each client with referrals in mind.combine all the five points together and you have a strategy that will put you way ahead of most of your competitors. many people think that all you have to do to…

  30. pop artist says:

    learn how to market online.another option you…

    have as an online writer is creating article packs. this way you can sell one pack to many people. you should sell only to people who don’t need unique articles.internet marketerdo you want to learn how online marketing works? do you…

  31. smaller pack is easier to bring. you…

    can also bring it with your when traveling.recovery labs undoubtedly provides nifty solutions to your common aches and pains. you might want to try their muscle melt bath to soothe tired and aching muscles after working out. their multivitamin capsules…

  32. daily regimen especially if you frequently dance,…

    exercise or train.recovery labs recovery cream in large size. bring this to the gym and share it with your friends or team mates. the will surely love its muscle soothing benefits. it has anti inflammatory properties that will immediately relieve muscl…

  33. that your company is not only focused…

    on selling to one demographic but that you care about all your customers equally. find content from other writers – writing a blog regularly can leave you searching for topics. the best way to do this is to subscribe and read…

  34. traffic to your website; therefore giving you…

    a higher chance of converting traffic into sales. hiring a blog writer means that you have a professional and experienced writer that is used to writing by weaving in pertinent keywords and also that is used to including call to actions…

  35. Airsoft says:

    Evike.com…

    Evike | Cheap Airsoft Accessories…