On Chad Billingsley’s New Contract (And Notes)

Fun fact: over two years ago, on January 26, 2009, I wrote about Zack Greinke‘s extension with the Royals and wondered how this might impact Chad Billingsley. (This was before Greinke’s ridiculous Cy Young 2009 and Billingsley’s second half collapse that year, remember.) At the time, this is what I proposed Billingsley could end up with:

I mean, there’s no longer any remaining question about whether we want him around, right? So why not buy out his three arbitration years and the first year of free agency with a 4 year, $36 million deal?

And what did Billingsley end up with yesterday?

Source: Billingsley’s three-year deal with the #Dodgers worth $35-36 million, including buyout of option for fourth year.

Okay, that was pretty close; if you include the $6.275m he’s making this year, it’s essentially a four year deal worth approximately $42m. I say “pretty close”, because at the time, it would be buying out all arb years with just one free agent year, while this deal is of course buying out more higher-priced free agent years. (I’ll ask you to kindly ignore that I also said at the time that Billingsley was definitely superior to Greinke, and allow me to pretend that I’m some sort of soothsayer over here.)

In all seriousness, however, I’m very satisfied with this deal, and I think it’s fair for both sides. Billingley’s always been somewhat underrated in my book; of the 87 pitchers who have thrown at least 400 innings since 2008, his FIP of 3.42 is tied for 14th with Ubaldo Jimenez. That’s better than names like Johan Santana, Jered Weaver, Roy Oswalt, Francisco Liriano, and Matt Cain. Is that an ace? I’ll save that discussion for another day, but if you wanted to say that more than half the teams in baseball don’t have a pitcher as good as he is, you could certainly make the argument. (Kershaw, of course, is 12th on that list, with the best still expected from him.) This also provides the team with some cost certainty, thus avoiding not only the question of what kind of arbitration deal he might be in line for next year, but what might happen when he hit the open market the year after.

Eric Stephen at TrueBlueLA and Jon Weisman at Dodger Thoughts are both also happy with the deal, comparing it to deals for Ricky Nolasco and Justin Verlander, respectively, and even better, Dave Cameron at FanGraphs thinks the Dodgers made out very well. It’s a long read, so I won’t paste it all, but here’s the fun takeaway:

Perhaps most interesting, however, is the extension that Wandy Rodriguez signed with the Astros just a few months ago. Rodriguez was in his final year of arbitration, so he was at the point where Billingsley would have been at the end of the 2011 season – when his new deal actually kicks in. Rodriguez signed a 3 year, $34 million extension with the Astros covering the same years that Billingsley just gave up to get some security. His career numbers – 985 innings, 62 wins, and a 4.18 ERA.

If, this year, Billingsley threw 160 innings, posted a 7.43 ERA, and won just three games, he would end the year with those same career numbers. If Wandy Rodriguez’s deal set the market for what the final year of arbitration and first two years of free agency are worth, Billingsley essentially locked in a price that would be fair (based on career numbers) if he was the worst pitcher in baseball this year.

Perhaps he really wanted to stay in Los Angeles, and he had motivations beyond simply squeezing the Dodgers for every last penny he could get. Whatever the reasoning, though, it seems pretty clear that Billingsley left a lot of money on the table with this deal.

Barring trades, you can now expect to see Billingsley alongside Clayton Kershaw for at least the next four seasons. That’s a beautiful thing, and for the more optimistic among us, it means it’s no longer totally unreasonable to think that we can dream about a front three of Kershaw, Billingsley, and Zach Lee one day. I’m very pleased with this deal from the team’s perspective, and even if Billingsley did leave some money on the table, well, he also just made about $35 million, so fair deal for both sides. Good job, Ned.

******

One update to my prospective 25-man roster: Jay Gibbons is likely to start the season on the disabled list due to his continuing vision problems. From a pure baseball perspective, this doesn’t bother me all that much; after all, I did argue just last week that he wasn’t worth a roster spot, and this does almost guarantee that Xavier Paul makes the club. Still, after all Gibbons has been through (some of it self-inflicted, to be sure), it’s tough to see his triumphant comeback story derailed by something as unexpected as this. This is actually a better scenario than an outright DFA, though, because not only does his $650k salary become guaranteed, he’ll be eligible for a rehab stint in the minors when he’s able, and assuming that takes a few weeks, we should have a lot more clarity on the roster situation at that point.

We don’t yet know who will get the extra spot, and you could argue that any of 4-5 names are in the mix. My strong preference has to be towards A.J. Ellis, however, because all indications are that Hector Gimenez is an emergency catcher at best.

******

Over at Baseball Prospectus, Ben Lindbergh has put together a list of positions where contending teams have decided to go with decidedly unpalatable options – guys like Jeff Mathis and Yuniesky Betancourt. It shouldn’t come as any surprise that the Dodger left field mess made the list.  

LF: Tony Gwynn Jr., Dodgers (.233 TAv, -0.6 WARP)

The Dodgers’ stillborn left-field timeshare really deserves a group mention here, but while Los Angeles may have chosen to stick a fork in the position, at least its other two tines—Jay Gibbons and Marcus Thames—project to earn positive value. Gwynn can’t hit, so he has to be truly extraordinary in the field to merit a roster spot, which FRAA doesn’t think he succeeded in doing last season. With Matt Kemp and Andre Ethier holding down center and right, respectively, Gwynn doesn’t figure to play much at the outfield’s more demanding positions, but he’ll likely be the starting left fielder for as long as Jay Gibbons can’t see. Since even a sighted Jay Gibbons doesn’t present much of an obstacle, Gwynn stands to see significant time. Unless he rediscovers the competent stroke he exhibited in 2009 or turns in another defensive performance FRAA can be proud of, that’s not good news for the Dodgers, who might soon find themselves missing the “Mannywood” sign.

While I attempted to look at the positives for Gwynn recently, I did so with a fair bit of wishcasting and plenty of “if’s”. If he can overcome a horrendous 2010. If he can hit at even a mildly acceptable a level. With Gibbons out, Gwynn will get the bulk of LF duties to prove himself, and I hope for everyone’s sake that he can do it, but it’s not hard to see where the doubt comes from.

******

Yes, Jonathan Broxton “blew a save” last night, and while I can’t believe we’re even discussing a blown save in an exhibition game, I’ll point out that Ivan DeJesus botched what would have been a game-ending double play, remind you that the winning run scored on a sacrifice fly, and let Jon Weisman’s words describe exactly how I feel:

I’m seriously considering complete abstention from debating the merits of Jonathan Broxton for the time being. The season hasn’t even started, and already the fur is flying about his value. No, he didn’t do his job. Neither did De Jesus, Jansen or Lilly, but no one will question their manhood. I’m willing to admit I’m concerned about whether Broxton’s all the way back from his late 2010 troubles, but I just don’t know if I can spend yet another year arguing about the man’s courage, spine or gumption. It’s completely subjective, and people are just going to believe what they want to believe.

I agree 100% with Jon on this; for whatever reason, the opinion of many towards Broxton is so skewed that if he struck out 99 of 100, they’d be asking what happened with the last guy. Still, I’m not sure I have the strength to do what Jon’s contemplating, and that’s avoiding the topic entirely once the season starts. I’ve been one of Broxton’s staunchest defenders, and even I’ve admitted that his rope is short if he doesn’t get off to a good start. All I ask is that we be fair about it, and realize that minor league second basemen booting ground balls have a pretty big impact on getting outs as well.

******

Selected thoughts from scouts on the Dodgers, courtesy of Tom Krasovic of the San Diego Union-Tribune:

“I think they’re going to be offensively challenged, and defensively challenged. The other day, (shortstop Rafael) Furcal was 4.9 running down the line, third baseman bobbles the ball and he’s still out in plenty of time. Saw (Matt) Kemp misplay two balls in the same game recently. He looks terrible in center field. Kenley Jansen is pretty damn impressive.”

“I like Xavier Paul more than the Dodgers do and would keep him over (Jay) Gibbons or (Tony) Gwynn Jr. Paul needs a change of scenery. His bat is OK. He has a good swing and can run the ball down. Hector Gimenez is a just a good-looking hitter. I’d take him as a backup. Ivan DeJesus, he’s stayed inside the ball well. Sands, I like his bat. He has a really nice swing. He looks OK in left field.”

“I think Rubby De La Rosa can pitch there right now and he’d be fine. He was up to 97 and good angle to plate, good feel for changeup, and I think the breaking ball will come. I think this guy’s a starter, and I don’t think he’s far away.”

“I think they’re going to be battling it out for third place with the Padres, and the Padres know how to play better.”

“They could be a disaster with all of the ifs.”

******

New ESPN SweetSpot blogger David Schoenfield has been putting together preseason All-Star teams for each division, and today he touches on the NL West. Of the eleven spots, four are Giants, and three each are from the Rockies and Diamondbacks. The Padres don’t merit a mention, and only Kershaw (as lefty starter) makes the list from the Dodgers.

0 comments

Trackbacks

  1. [...] just never makes it easy on us, does he? When he signed a new contract just before Opening Day that ties him to the Dodgers through 2014, most of us roundly [...]

  2. [...] in Alex Castellanos. Oh, and he signed Chad Billingsley to a reasonably priced three-year deal, which was nice, and even though it completely failed to work out, trying to go overboard in pitching depth by [...]

  3. you offer.10) proofread for accuracy. this is…

    as important with blogs as it is with any other type of writing. spelling and grammatical errors will make you look unprofessional.a blog can be very effective as part of your marketing campaign as it can ensure that your website copywriting…

  4. I love this says:

    a blog or have been at it…

    for a while, if you want to be truly successful there are keys to making your blog the best it can be. you may have a striking blog design that attracts lots of visitors, but that alone won’t keep them coming…

  5. franchise says:

    this means as well.this way someone can…

    subscribe to your blog through kindle and pay $0.99 a month to get what you publish.so i hope you see what i am trying to do, which is to help you create some income so that it can sustain you until…

  6. analysis says:

    a tall big boned woman might require…

    significantly more calories.dieting after having a baby requires the dieter to consider her unique situation. if she is breast feeding, she needs to consume more calories than she needs for herself; she needs to have enough energy to produce her baby’…

  7. that are written by real people who…

    are good professionals in what they write about.blogospherecouple of years ago blogs has become a good place to advertise services, goods and other things by writing quality reviews, airing ones point of view or sharing your knowledge with others. toda…

  8. past experiences and the skills that you…

    already possess. i’m going to show you three quick and dirty ways to make income online, by working as much or as little as you want, from anywhere in the world, whenever you choosefreelance writingonline freelance writing jobs are plentiful, if…

  9. design that will make your blog standout,…

    and you have to write initial posts for it to look active.web design is tiring, yet we can temporarily solve it by purchasing readily available templates on the web. however, we can’t just buy and copy-paste articles from the web; we…

  10. you work in the web design world…

    and there is a major story about a company being hacked, then you should be writing about website security and how to protect your interests for example.look at others – although you should never copy anyone’s work, there is no harm…

  11. Oro Gold says:

    you get quality opt ins, get to…

    work! start conducting short surveys for your product and have them come back for a couple popularity polls that you can build for your niche. it not only builds trust in the person behind the curtain who is working hard, but…

  12. your ideas and message will always shine…

    through. our readers will always find value in the truth we write about. so in order to draw them in, do your research and find out what they are interested in. with this you can choose which poems closely relate to…

  13. here says:

    be digesting information and therefore increasing your…

    own knowledge.the google wonder wheel:this is a great tool and excellent for finding new subjects to write about. all you have to do is type in a particular subject and google wonder wheel will show you lots of other search terms…

  14. importantly, article submission sites rely on good…

    quality content which they know will provide value to their readers. it is good to try and find a hidden sub-category to write around to provide new breakthrough content.once you have found your subject area and have some good understanding of…

  15. to read the article and make a…

    comment that is relevant to it. why is this important? simple. dofollow blog commenting is a highly effective means for getting backlinks. if you do not make relevant comments that get approved, those backlinks will simply never get published… bottom…

  16. are placed at crucial places in the…

    entire content according to specific density rate. based on the keywords, the search engines determine the rank of your website. higher ranking obviously helps in generating more traffic to your site, facilitating your online business. now, to create a…

  17. you can hire an experienced seo article…

    writer or a writer who has recently graduated to deliver on the calibers of services you want to pay for.tip # 5 – don’t forget to find out who exactly will be working on your project. sometimes, seo writers are associated…

  18. remember: follow these tips on how to…

    make money fast online.contrary to the popular notion, making money with a website only requires small capital. gone are the days when you need to understand html or hire web designers to build you a site and pay a hefty price….

  19. posts is crucial as well. a well-crafted…

    headline will draw people in but your content must keep them interested. once you hook in a reader, the real challenge is getting them to come back. writing web content should be considered no different to writing offline content when it…

  20. seguros says:

    services provided by article marketing companies. this…

    way, the business owner simply provides a bit of instruction about the subject matter and intended audience for an entire group of pre-screened writers to review. the business owner can select an individual blog post writer for hire based upon his…

  21. here says:

    what structure they use and see how…

    you can use this with your site. remember you can always edit your blog, and change things around, nothing is set in stone. once you start a blog keep all the posts a consistent style, this will keep the blog looking…

  22. joining it is very important following the…

    guidelines of the company that may be seo article writing company or just article writing company. in any case the writer can make good only by following the guidelines issues. resources that are used by the companies for prospective as well…

  23. Mac väska says:

    research first. it’s “very” important that you…

    research the keyword phrases that people are using to look for information online. this will help you in deciding what niche is best for you. chances are that any niche you participate in will have some competition now. there simply are…

  24. seb paskolos says:

    that your blog ebbs and flows well…

    from one paragraph to the next. even if you’d prefer not to learn too much about grammar or spelling, there is software that will do it for you! how fortunate are we? that anyone can become a writer, no matter what…

  25. new things such as failure and defeat…

    for you to be able to accept that there are things that you need to do perfect your skills.find a writer’s group near you and join them. this group will consist of writers who have experience over the years and have…

  26. always write a post to teach them…

    something. offer tips and advice on how to solve problem. use examples and interviews to get your point across. writing a blog post doesn’t have to be a difficult thing to accomplish. just remember that if the information is helpful, chances…

  27. relevant ads that relate to this subject.but…

    if you continually wrote about basketball, and kept your keywords intact so that adsense can get a good idea of what you are writing about, you can expect to serve up ads that relate to the content that you’re writing about…

  28. tech-house says:

    extra mile.2. i suggest that you write…

    “how to” articles. i cannot express myself any more passionately when i tell you that they are truly designed to drive traffic. every successful blog will include “how to” articles at least 3 times a week. simply write an article that…

  29. Swanky Tunes says:

    try to find blogs that allow you…

    to place dofollow links and also have higher page rank. by higher pagerank, i am talking anything more than page rank two.the guideline is that you simply should only contribute comments whenever your response is really informative. 90% of blogs utiliz…

  30. Airsoft says:

    Evike.com…

    Looking for the highest quality paintball guns around? Find them all at Evike.com, home to everything Airsoft and paitball….