How Much Money Is Matt Kemp Earning Himself?


Before 2010, Matt Kemp avoided arbitration by signing a two-year deal worth about $11 million. That deal expires at the end of this season, and Kemp will be arbitration-eligible for a final time in 2012 before reaching free agency at the end of next year. Kemp, of course, is putting up a season that looks more and more like it’ll be one of the best in Dodger history, as he’s on pace to hit 46 homers and steal 37 bases to go along with his .335/.420/.638 line. As the season goes on and the pennant race becomes a more and more distant dream, his contract situation is going to become a hot conversation piece. You can bet that he won’t be settling for two years and $11m again, but just how much money has he made himself with his performance this year?

Any conversation like this must immediately be prefaced with the usual disclaimer about deadbeat owner Frank McCourt and the uncertain financial situation in which the Dodgers find themselves. McCourt’s holding on to the ownership of this club on a bi-weekly basis as he scrambles to make each payroll, so it’s impossible to know what the situation will be when the season ends four months from now. Perhaps McCourt has managed to hang on until then. Maybe MLB will have taken over. It’s unlikely, but possible, that a sale could be in motion by then – or it could be some other scenario we can’t even dream about yet. None of that is going to change the fact that Matt Kemp is an extremely valuable asset who is going to get his money, so let’s pretend for the moment that we’re fans of a real team with responsible owners, and not the disaster we find ourselves in. (Additionally: minutes before I was to post this, I saw that Bill Shaikin is reporting that the McCourts have come to a settlement. We know none of the details yet, but Shaikin, Molly Knight, and Josh Fisher are usually nails on this story, so I won’t let the unknown there delay this post.)

Jon Heyman recently reported that Ned Colletti had initial conversations with Kemp’s agent, Dave Stewart, about a long-term deal, though clearly nothing has come of it yet. Despite Stewart’s well-publicized criticism of the Dodgers last season, that clearly seems to have blown over with the new on-field regime, and he and Colletti did just work together to sign Chad Billingsley to a deal earlier this year. I think every Dodger fan would like to see a long-term deal worked out, but let’s start small first.

What if Kemp goes to arbitration?

The record award for a position player in his third year of arbitration was the $15.5m that Prince Fielder got from the Brewers this past winter. Like Kemp, Fielder was coming off of a two-year deal and had not previously been to arbitration, though his deal had been for $18m, more than Kemp’s $11m. Arbitration panels are notorious for relying upon “old school” stats rather than more advanced methods, so we’ll stick with that here. In 2010, Fielder hit .261 with 32 homers and 83 RBI, scoring 94 runs. Kemp is on pace to top all of those marks this year. As if those numbers didn’t give him enough of an advantage over Fielder, he’s also on pace to steal the 37 bases, while playing a much more valuable defensive position. While Kemp is certainly going to be headed into the process with a better season in his pocket than Fielder, he’s also coming off a smaller contract and an uneven 2010. Those two factors mean that he may not break Fielder’s record, though it wouldn’t be surprising to see him come close. I could see Kemp getting anywhere from $13m-$15m in arbitration.

What if Kemp signs a long-term deal?

This assumes that Kemp wants to sign such a deal with the Dodgers. Outwardly he’s said all the right things, but we can’t really know for sure how frustrated he is with the current mess at the top and lack of talent around him, whether he’s enjoyed hitting on the road so much that he’d rather be away from Dodger Stadium more often, or whether he’d just prefer to be nearer to his Oklahoma roots. For the purposes of this exercise, we’ll figure he’ll want to stay. But at what cost? Let’s compare him to the two outfielders who signed $100m deals last winter, Jayson Werth and Carl Crawford. Like Kemp, each can kind-of sort-of play center field, but are much better situated in an outfield corner. (Age and stats for Werth and Crawford are through 2010, Kemp is to-date.)

Kemp compares favorably to both, and don’t forget that he still has the remainder of this season to complete; at his current pace he’ll overake Werth in WAR and lead all three in home runs. He’s the youngest of the three, and will likely be coming off the best season of any of them.  On the surface, your initial thought might be, “he’s going to get seven years and $130m”.

But while it’s fun to compare him to Werth and Crawford, it’s not entirely accurate. Each were free agents, able to play multiple teams off each other for the highest offer, and Kemp will not have that luxury until after 2012. His negotiating ability is somewhat limited by the fact that he’s still under Dodger control for another year and can’t go out to speak with other teams. So a more accurate comparison would be to players who have signed extensions with their teams that bought out a year or two of arbitration… and that’s where we run into problems.

After doing some research, I’ve found that it’s incredibly difficult to find a good comparison to Kemp. Players of his youth and talent rarely reach the open market, and often don’t even get as close to it as he will. (Crawford made it because everyone knew the cash-strapped Rays couldn’t afford the extension; the Phillies have so many other big-ticket deals that they couldn’t squeeze Werth in as well. Fielder and possibly Albert Pujols are likely to be good case studies this winter.) When I put the question to Twitter last night, looking for extensions that had been signed at a similar point in a player’s career, I got a lot of good suggestions, but none that were close enough. Evan Longoria signed his extension about a week into his MLB career. Hanley Ramirez, David Wright, Dustin Pedroia, Carlos Gonzalez and Justin Upton each signed after roughly two full seasons. Jay Bruce, Nick Markakis and Ryan Zimmerman signed before their first trips to arbitration. Ryan Braun signed an eight-year deal in his second season, then had a bizarre 5/$105m extension added which doesn’t even kick in until 2016. Kemp will have over five years of service time when this season ends – just one more of team control -  and that makes these calculations difficult.

The closest comparables I was able to find were Troy Tulowitzki and Ryan Howard, who each recently signed $100m+ deals to stay with their current clubs. Neither comp is perfect, for reasons I’ll state in a second, but for the moment let’s compare Kemp’s numbers to theirs. (Age and stats for Tulowitzki and Howard are through 2010, Kemp is to-date.)

Tulowitzki, like Kemp, made his debut in the summer of 2006. But he’s also a quality defensive shortstop, and hadn’t gone year-to-year like Kemp; after just over one full season, he signed a 6/$31m contract following 2007. When he signed his mammoth 10/$157.5m deal after 2010, it replaced the final three years of that deal. Howard’s situation is even more complicated (and controversial). He’s older than both and plays a less valuable position, and won a $10m contract in his first year of arbitration in 2008, then signed a 3/$54m deal to avoid going to arbitration a second time in 2009. That deal would have bought out his arbitration years and made him a free agent after this season… except that in April of 2010, the Phillies tacked on a ludicrous 5/$125m extension that doesn’t even kick in until 2012. If Kemp keeps up his current pace, he’ll top Tulo’s WAR and would come close to matching Howard’s.

All of which is a long way of saying, there hasn’t been a recent example like Kemp to point to. If he decides to play out his last year and hit the market, and has another good year in 2012, he’s likely looking at a massive $100m+ contract somewhere. If he signs a deal with the Dodgers, he’ll still get a hefty fee, but without the open market at play he’d probably have to leave some money on the table in exchange for avoiding the risk that would come with an injury or poor performance next season.

So let’s spitball this. It seems clear that if he finishes this season the way he started it, Kemp’s value on the open market could be between $15m-$20m a year. (I’m doing my best to avoid the fact that Howard got $25m a year well into his 30s, which is so insane I can’t even talk about it.) If he signed with the Dodgers (again, acting like we follow a real team) following 2011, he’d probably get on the lower end of that because he’s not a free agent and would pass up the 2012 risk. He’s also young enough that he might not want a 7-8 year deal like we’ve seen here, figuring that he could sign another big deal at around 31. So let’s start the bidding at… 5 years, $80m. Would you do that? Would he?

0 comments

Trackbacks

  1. [...] How Much Money Is Matt Kemp Earning Himself?: Mike Scioscia’s tragic illness takes a look at the kind of payday Kemp is going to get if he keeps up his monster pace so far in 2011. [...]

  2. [...] Mike Scioscia’s Tragic Illness tries to figure out how much money Matt Kemp is making himself this season. [...]

  3. [...] A week later, I looked at how much it might cost to sign Kemp to a long-term deal. I settled on starting with 5/$80m, a number which I admit seems quite low now, but remember that at the time he’d had just two good months after his disappointing 2010, and 1.5 years of team control remaining. I think it’s clear that it’s $100m+ at this point. [...]

  4. can become skilled at. thanks a lot!…

    resources like the one you mentioned here will be very useful to me! i will post a link to this page on my blog. i am sure my visitors will find that very useful you got a really useful blog. i…

  5. your blog. when you guest blogging, it…

    is imperative to wow them so they will want to read more. a great design will also attract others to your blog before they even read the content. interacting with blog comments is also important. if you interact with your readers…

  6. here says:

    just write what is in your head….

    write your thoughts and feelings. you could also talk to yourself out loud then write down the words that come out. doing these simple activities with a specific topic in mind will get you into some point where you could actually…

  7. franchise says:

    an expert and you need help with…

    the whole concept of promoting your website you should turn to a writer that understands seo very well. look for the seo firms that offer complete packages for promotion of web site and get advice for your particular site and keyword.communicationsomet…

  8. fit what the community likes to see…

    for each social networking site you choose to share your blog post with.another way to is to find groups and brands within these social networking sites that may be interested in reading your blog post. you can post on their walls…

  9. searching the internet for stories and different…

    news angles and potential customers looking for your products and services.2. one of the top benefits of writing blogs is to build your profile online and attract attention for your keywords.if you’re not sure what i mean by keywords, they’re basical…

  10. internet. number 1 is google and number…

    2 is facebook. so you can stand to get a ton of traffic from youtube simply and easily.to make youtube work for you, limit your videos to around 4-5 minutes long. focus on giving your viewers great information that they can…

  11. newest and by far the most popular…

    form of internet advertising. while other obvious forms of advertising are becoming repetitive and less effective, it is taking over the market as the best way to spread the word.so, what is it all about, and why is it such a…

  12. click here says:

    such posts are not recommended. many web…

    visitors and readers do not have time to read lengthy posts and many avoid such posts. keep your posts and straight to the point. most importantly, use a language that is easy for clients to comprehend and rest assured of the…

  13. but getting them, your name and your…

    blog name out in front of as many people as you can is the name of the game. to help win the game, i recommend you start networking, besides it’s a lot cheaper and effective than google adwords. guest blogging is…

  14. your computer. this helps a great deal…

    in increasing your typing speed.use more fingersit is common logic that instead of using two fingers, if you use 5-8, the delivery will be much speedier. many users have the habit of typing one letter at a time with a single…

  15. other “quality” violations like spelling and grammar…

    mistakes. a catchy title that creates an impact is the essence of blog writing. readers shall base their decision to read the article through only after looking at the title. as for search engines – include your strongest search terms (keywords)…

  16. marketing activities because if you don’t, you…

    could find yourself spending hours on facebook and not much to show for it.it’s easy for it to turn into a distraction instead of a productive venture.facebook is all about building relationships and stronger connections.as a small service business ow…

  17. this visitor is upset and confused because…

    of all the advertising. so, they decide to close the tap on their internet browser. this happens often to other bloggers. don’t let it happen to you. i suggest that you write very clean blog posts and focus on the topic…

  18. gay porn says:

    Title…

    Man that was weird. I just wrote an extremely long response but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t show up. Hmmm… well I’m not writing all that again. Anyways, just wanted to say fantastic blog…almost as cool as http://google.com!…

  19. to be “ms eggerson the english teacher”…

    to know how to use proper grammar but you do need to check over your content & use the spell check button.7) not responding to questions & comments: if someone takes the time to leave a comment or ask you a…

  20. Title…

    Ugh, I just wrote a huge comment, but it disappeared when I hit send. Anyway, I’m not going to redo it again, so I just wanted to say nice blog! Better than http://google.com! :-)…

  21. post will consist of all these things….

    in fact, i suggest that you spill the beans. give them your best information. if you can get these people to trust you, they will love your posts.3. when you write a blog post, think about people’s attention spans. you see,…

  22. can attempt to write these articles yourself,…

    but there are things that the search engines want you to do in order for you to get placed on their websites. the company you use will understand all of the things that can get you in trouble and with no…

  23. evaluate the quality of a blog article…

    purchased if you cannot do it yourself. there are quite a few mothers who are both happy and not so happy after the birth of a child. they are quite happy seeing the arrival of a new one in their house…

  24. in moderation as frames might affect the…

    professionalism of the blog. all these are very important tips for blogging. create a blog and really get your message out there to around 2 billion people who now use the internet worldwide. in this article we’ll look at the ways…

  25. website says:

    who their audiences are. misunderstanding the audience…

    simply means that the topic is right but you do not connect with the audience. as a blogger, it is wise to understand the problems that your audiences are facing so that you may convey helpful information that will solve their…

  26. tablet says:

    that might type in those keywords. now…

    i will formulate a sentence that pulls everything together.for example: “are you slaving over trying to write good blog posts to generate traffic, but you’re feeling discouraged because you’re working hard and not seeing any results?” (the opening …

  27. or post your first article as soon…

    as possible, just write it directly from there or just paste your title and the article body. you can also add an image, enter your tags and categories then click to publish instantly.if you have further questions regarding html codes, track…

  28. Titanic says:

    other zones.native and non-native english speaking writers…

    comparisonin result, much of the contents written by the so called native english speaking writers float over the heads of the reader or viewer and in addition; Titanic most of the times the grammar, punctuation, and spellings are too inferior in stand…

  29. Mac väska says:

    obtained a person’s email address. it’s good…

    to know where the email address came from. was it from social media, a lead nurturing campaign, maybe from an interesting blog post? it’s always a good idea to separate an email list into groups of top-of-funnel acquisition channels. make sure…

  30. 3. make sure that headings to have…

    the main keywords.on the other hand, you can highlight some important words or phrases, words that are much likely to be searched over the internet.paragraphs should not contain more than 3 or 4 phrases. one ideea, one paragraph, because having paragra…

  31. stick with your goal of becoming the…

    best article writer and one day, you will become the best there is. introductionblogging is very much popular these days. people adore writing about everything they face every day and share their experience with other bloggers and Titanic internet surf…

  32. Title…

    Ugh, I just typed a long comment, but it disappeared when I clicked send. Anyway, I’m not going to retype it again, so I just wanted to say nice blog! Better than http://facebook.com! :-)…

  33. Title…

    Ugh, I just typed a huge comment, but it disappeared when I hit send. Anyway, I’m not going to retype it again, so I just wanted to say nice blog! Better than http://google.com! :-)…

  34. Yelp says:

    to learn in order to attract blog…

    traffic that is targeted for your specific niche or program. using the methods to attract organic traffic are not only going to help you generate a lot of site visitors, but also have a tendency to stick around for a long…

  35. Title…

    Wow, I’m so delighted that I clicked on this page, super info here! Better than http://facebook.com!…

  36. tours says:

    Title…

    Ugh, I just wrote a mega comment, but it disappeared when I clicked send. Anyway, I’m not going to redo it again, so I just wanted to say great blog! Better than http://facebook.com! :-)…

  37. Title…

    Ugh, I just typed a mega comment, but it disappeared when I hit send. Anyway, I’m not going to redo it again, so I just wanted to say great blog! Better than http://facebook.com! :-)…

  38. Title…

    Ugh, I just wrote a mega comment, but it disappeared when I clicked send. Anyway, I’m not going to retype it again, so I just wanted to say great blog! Better than http://google.com! :-)…

  39. bring you greater opportunities. most clients are…

    looking for content that will drive up the web traffic to their sites, so they apply seo techniques when generating their content. if they decide to hire a writer, they will prefer someone who is already familiar with the requirements of…

  40. expect to get yourself in-front of people…

    if you don’t have a compelling title to get their attention. want to know a secret? target their emotions. some people might think this is wrong but here’s the thing, that is what marketing and writing is all about. believe it…

  41. that people should want to come to…

    your blog for its information, humor, or whatever it is that your site provides. spammy comments will convey the wrong message and they benefit no one.#4) become more socially activeuse twitter, facebook, and google+ to share your latest posts and comm…

  42. just a couple of really distinct points,…

    and make sure you weave in some of your insight about why you believe this prediction may be correct. you can create a lot of discussion by using this style of posting.write a serieslet’s say you have a lot to write…

  43. pet website says:

    keep reading and come back for more….

    make sure to showcase personality even on a topic that doesn’t warrant much.personality should shine through in the titles, introduction, side notes and posts – but be yourself, not someone else.be consistentreaders do not want to read a post and have…

  44. remix artist says:

    secretary would be a good choice.if you…

    do not have a dedicated person to handle the task of writing blog posts, you can outsource the job to a professional ghost writer. some very good writers may charge as little as $20 per article, assuming you have an ongoing…

  45. writing will not get you the traffic…

    you want. another thing that won’t fly is writing that is merely fluff with no substance. when you post on your blog make sure you have something of value to say, and say it well.provide accurate informationbe sure that what you…

  46. Title…

    Ugh, I just wrote a mega comment, but it disappeared when I hit send. Anyway, I’m not going to redo it again, so I just wanted to say cool blog! Better than http://facebook.com! :-)…

  47. Airsoft says:

    Evike.com…

    Evike | Airsoft Lights and Lasers…

  48. tatuaggi says:

    Title…

    Ugh, I just typed a long comment, but it disappeared when I clicked send. Anyway, I’m not going to retype it again, so I just wanted to say great blog! Better than http://facebook.com! :-)…