2011 Midseason Grades: Offense


The All-Star break is here, and that means it’s everyone’s favorite time of the year: midseason grades. It’s been a tough year for the Dodgers on and off the field, though we do of course have the pleasure of a few exceptionally bright spots. As always, the grades are in relation to what was reasonably expected of the player at the beginning of the season, not in comparison to other players in the bigs. Otherwise, Jose Bautista would get an A, and no one else would get above a Q. Fewer than 50 plate appearances or 10 innings pitched gets you an incomplete.

All stats are via baseball-reference. Today we’ll do hitters, and before the break is over we’ll get to pitchers, management, and one new kind of review. As always, these letter grades are subjective opinions and meant more for fun than anything. Except for Juan Uribe’s. There’s nothing fun about Juan Uribe.

Catchers

Rod Barajas D+ (.220/.262/.385 8hr 0.2 WAR)
And right off the bat, our rating system is being tested. Do I give Barajas an F, because he’s not any good, or a C, because we never expected him to be any good? I’ll go with a D+, because even though he’s underperforming his own mediocre career stats, he was still second on the team in homers until the final game before the break. I suppose that says a lot more about the Dodgers than it does about him, though. Due to the low bar for offense from catching in the bigs, he’s actually slightly above replacement, though it’s hard to look at the 46/8 K/BB without getting a little ill. He’s due to be activated from the disabled list on Friday, allowing us to start up the always fun “Navarro or Ellis?” game again. (It’ll be Navarro sticking, of course.)

Dioner Navarro F (.183/.234/.287 2hr -0.1 WAR)
You don’t need me to go back and really find all of the articles I wrote over the winter asking why he was worth a $1m major-league contract and why he was guaranteed a spot over the likely superior A.J. Ellis, right? Navarro came in with the lowest of expectations, yet after missing the first month with an oblique injury, has somehow still managed to underperform. Despite that, he still manages to come up with the game on the line in the ninth inning nearly every single night. The world is a twisted place.

Fun fact: Navarro is the only player in history with the name “Dioner”. Fun fact #2: he’s still looking for his first hit against a lefty in fourteen tries this season.

A. J. Ellis (C) (.222/.364/.222 0hr -0.1 WAR)
I realize I’ve heaped far more praise on a 30-year-old minor league lifer with absolutely no power than he really deserves, but the Dodger catching situation is dire, and his long minor-league record and short major league stints show an above-average ability to get on base, which is exactly what this lineup is missing. Defensively, I won’t insult your intelligence by citing CERA, but it’s hard to think it’s a coincidence that Chad Billingsley’s mid-season slump turned around precisely when Ellis started being his regular catcher. Too bad he’s almost certainly headed back for Barajas on Friday.

Hector Gimenez (inc.) (.143/.143/.143 0hr -0.1 WAR)
I would like to say something witty or insightful about Hector Gimenez, but that infers that I have absolutely any recollection of him as a Dodger whatsoever. Pass.

Infielders

James Loney (C-) (.268/.311/.342 4hr -0.5 WAR)
I feel weird giving Loney a C-, because his line and a grade in that range suggest that he was his normal mediocre self all season. Far from it; by early May, he was the most hated man in LA since OJ and we were all writing articles about how bad his season was going to be on a historical level. Since then, he’s basically been the best non-Kemp hitter on the team. That doesn’t mean he’s good – hooray, a .751 OPS from a 1B since April 26! – and again, that says a lot about the rest of the players on this team, but nothing tells you more about the plight of the 2011 Dodgers than the fact that their punchless overpaid first baseman is no longer even close to being the biggest issue here.

Jamey Carroll (A+) (.297/.368/.366 0hr 1.6 WAR)
Last season, Carroll had a .718 OPS and was largely hailed as the team MVP for stepping in to cover for Rafael Furcal at shortstop for nearly the entire season. For a 36-year-old career backup who had played in more than 113 just once, it was quite the impressive feat. More impressive? The fact that he’s exceeding that this year, currently with a .734 OPS. In a lower run scoring environment, that’s good for a 111 OPS+. Once again, the team has been crushed by injuries. Once again, Jamey Carroll has risen to the occasion and more. I’m not sure what the future holds for Carroll in Los Angeles – this is the last year of his contract, and unsurprisingly teams are showing trade interest – but he has consistently outperformed expectations. I’ll miss him when he’s gone.

Fun Carroll fact: since you know I have no use for RBI, regard this as more of a fun statistical quirk than any sort of value judgement, but he has somehow managed to step to the plate 311 times and drive in just 8 runners. I suppose that’s what happens when you don’t hit homers and you’re either batting leadoff (behind the pitcher and the horrible bottom of the lineup) or 8th (behind low-OBP guys like Uribe, Barajas, and Loney).

Aaron Miles
(A) (.318/.337/.381 1hr 1.1 WAR)
Credit where credit is due: Aaron Miles has been a really, really nice part of this team. I hardly need to remind you about all the jokes we made at his expense when he was signed and in the spring, but after being forced into far more playing time than anyone expected, he’s responded by becoming arguably the 4th-best hitter on the team. (Like Barajas and his homers, that says a lot more about the other hitters on the club, but still). We expected absolutely nothing from him – less than nothing, perhaps – and not only has he stepped up where needed, he led the NL in batting average in June.

It’s not all that simple, of course. .300 average or not, he’s not walking and he provides zero power, so his OPS is just barely over .700, and his .344 BABIP, 35 points over his career average, seems unlikely to hold. So let’s not get too caught up in praise for Miles to pretend he’s actually, you know, good. But for a non-roster guy who was something like the 8th infielder entering the season? Well done, Aaron. Well done.

Hey, you think we can sucker some team into trading for him at the deadline?

Ivan DeJesus, Jr. (inc.) (.188/.235/.188 0hr -0.5 WAR)
So far, DeJesus looks to be this year’s winner of the “Blake DeWitt Memorial LA-to-ABQ Frequent Flyer” award, because he saw three different stints with the big club, including the pleasure of flying all the way to Cincinnati for the pleasure of one pinch-hitting appearance in June. That being the case, you can’t really judge his big-league performance too much, though he also didn’t do a lot to change my perception of him as a bench player at best. Back in ABQ, he’s hitting .304, which is nice, though a .758 OPS in that environment isn’t encouraging.

Fun fact: for a guy whose name isn’t exactly “John Smith“, Ivan DeJesus is neither the best Ivan or the best DeJesus to play in the bigs this year.

Juan Uribe (oh holy good lord, F, and I don’t just mean the letter grade) (.207/.273/.306 4hr 0.4 WAR)
Uribe has been so bad that there’s an entire Tumblr dedicated to how sad he looks and makes us feel. He’s so bad that when an obviously fantastical rumor popped up for about five seconds about how the Dodgers might be looking to send him back to San Francisco, we jumped on it even though we knew it was BS, just for the small amount of hope it brought. He’s been so bad that he had a lousy April (.247/.303/.420) and hasn’t come close to even matching that since. He’s been so bad that of all the players in the bigs with at least 200 plate appearances, only three have a lower TAv than him. He’s been so bad that he has just one homer since April turned into May, and even that came off Brad Penny, so I feel like he was just trolling us. But hey, not like we have to stare at him for 2.5 more years or anything.

The funny part is, he’s actually been so good in the field that it pushes him above replacement level. That 0.4 breaks down into -0.4 oWAR and 0.8 dWAR. It doesn’t make him a good player, and it doesn’t justify the contract, but it’s something. I suppose that something should probably be enough to get him more than an F, but… no.

Rafael Furcal F (.185/.227/.228 1hr -0.5 WAR)
How do you even judge Furcal at this point? It can’t be on health, because he’s managed to end up on the disabled list twice more this year (though at least it wasn’t his back this time). It’s hard to do so on production, since he’s constantly either just about to go on the disabled list or just coming back from it. I suppose the fact that he’s not in a full body cast is something, but that line above… yeesh. Anyone who’s still dreaming of trading him to someone at the deadline probably needs to wake up because unfortunately, Furcal’s best days are behind him. As, probably, are his days of being able to obtain health insurance when he’s no longer a ballplayer.

Dee Gordon C+ (.232/.250/.280 0hr 0.0 WAR)
We all knew Gordon was recalled far too soon, and it showed: he was overmatched at the plate and made some critical errors in the field. He also brought the kind of excitement that we haven’t seen in years, if ever. If you have any doubt about that, just head on over to this GIF-heavy recap of the amazing feats he pulled off in just a single game. A lot of players end up with 0.0 WAR because they’ve been boring or barely playable, and haven’t contributed anything either positive or negative. That’s not the case with Gordon; he did plenty of things that hurt the team, but he made up for them with a ton of positives. That’s how it all evens out, and for a raw 23-year-old, yeah, I’ll take that.

Juan Castro A (.286/.333/.286 0hr 0.0 WAR)
Castro gave us the greatest gift of all, retiring this week before subjecting us to a fifth stint as a Dodger. That alone gets the man an A.

Casey Blake D- (.243/.346/.386 4hr 0.3 WAR)
Things the 37-year-old Blake has been on the disabled list for this season: sore oblique, infected elbow, pinched nerve in neck, Legionnaire’s disease, athlete’s thumb, bone-itis, ringworm infestation, osteoporosis. Also, he narrowly avoided a brush with the law for continually yelling at those damned kids to get off his lawn.

Casey Blake is old.

Russ Mitchell (inc.) (.115/.258/.269 1hr 0.1 WAR)
Mitchell has 74 MLB plate appearances in his short career. He has nine hits, and though one was a game-tying homer in the 9th inning against the White Sox earlier this year, that’s good for an OPS+ of 29. That’s an unfairly small sample size, of course, but he’s also hitting .244 in ABQ right now. Russ Mitchell: nope.

Outfielders

Jerry Sands (C-) (.200/.294/.328 2hr -0.4 WAR)
Like Gordon, Sands was probably promoted too soon, and like Gordon, he didn’t really provide results, but did provide hope for the future. All of the stories we heard about his maturity and plate approach seemed to be true, yet so far it hasn’t translated into production. Sands is crushing the ball once again in ABQ, and with the Dodger offense still stagnant, we’ll see him back up in blue before very long.

Tony Gwynn (B-) (.256/.316/.326 0hr 0.6 WAR)
It’s been something of an interesting season for Gwynn. He was his normal Gwynn-like self in April (i.e. bad), hitting .264/.291/.377 before going completely off the rails in May: he managed just two hits all month and received only four starts, as Sands took over the bulk of the left field work. At that point, with his batting average below .200 and with nothing to his name other than two game-saving catches, we started wondering how long he’d stick on the roster, especially when he didn’t get into any of the first three games in June. On June 4, he entered in the 8th inning and got two hits in a game that went 11 innings. He got a hit the next game, and the next, and before you knew it he’d hit in 7 of the first 8 games of the month. It would get better – since June 26, which was two weeks ago yesterday, he’s had five multihit games, including three with three and one with four. Now that Sands and Gordon are both in the minors, he’s effectively taken over as both the starting left fielder and leadoff hitter. Because he owns the only plus glove in what is a subpar defensive outfield, this was the outcome we’d always wanted. Now let’s see if he can really keep it up.

Marcus Thames
F (.197/.243/.333 2hr -0.6 WAR)
Injured? Yep, twice, even if only one led to a DL stint. Poor on defense? You better believe it. Unproductive on offense? Well, the line above doesn’t lie, right? I sure hope he’s renting, not buying.

Jay Gibbons
F (.255/.323/.345 1hr -0.5 WAR)
Well, he got DFA’d and claimed by no one, placing him back in AAA, so it couldn’t have been that good of a first half, right? You want to feel bad because his vision problems really derailed last season’s feel-good story right from the start… but then you remember he wasn’t really ever that good in the first place. The best part of that -0.5 WAR is that his oWAR is actually 0.1… meaning he’s really, really bad in the field.

JaMarcus Gwybbons, Jr. D-
Remember when the left field situation was going to be a nice trio between Gwynn, Thames, and Gibbons? Sheesh. Until Gwynn’s hot spurt over the last few weeks, they combined to offer absolutely nothing. Less than nothing, if you just went by WAR. At various points this season, we’ve made arguments for DFA’ing all three of them. Count this under “plans that were unlikely to work and then did, in fact, not work.”

Trent Oeltjen (inc.) (.265/.386/.441  1hr 0.6 WAR)
Hey, remember when Oeltjen went 4-4 with a homer in that 15-0 drubbing of Minnesota? That was rad, right? Unfortunately for him, he had 3 hits in 20 PA before that game, and just 2 hits in 20 PA since. 

Xavier Paul (inc.) (.273/.273/.273 0hr -0.1 WAR)
Paul’s ultimate contribution to the 2011 Dodgers is managing to grab a left field start before his departure, thus helping us push towards our ultimate goal of setting a record for most left fielders in a season. He’s got an 84 OPS+ for Pittsburgh since being picked up, though he’s improved his OPS in each full month there.

Jamie Hoffmann (inc.) (.000/.000/.000 0hr -0.2 WAR)
The man got four plate appearances. Let’s not infer too much from that. I still think he could be a pretty useful fourth outfielder in the bigs, as he’s a well-regarded defender having another high-OBP season in the minors, this time with a little pop.

Eugenio Velez (inc.) (.000/.000/.000 0hr -0.2 WAR)

Baron Ironglove von Pickoff. Still can’t believe he’s a Dodger. Or a major leaguer. Or a human being.

Matt Kemp (A+++) (.313/.398/.584 22hr 27sb 5.7 WAR)
I know you come here for informed baseball analysis and all (uh, I hope), and I could write 10,000 words on why Kemp is awesome. I will at some point, and 9,990 of those words will probably be about how I always said that he’d have a monstrous season this year, even as half the city was tearing him apart last year. There will be a time for that sort of insight, but for now, let’s leave it at this: 91 games into the season, Kemp has 5.7 WAR. That puts him on pace for about 9.9 WAR over the full season… a mark bettered by just two Dodgers in history. Yeah. His season is that good. Remember when everyone wanted to trade him, secure in the knowledge that he had neither the baseball IQ or work ethic to become a star? Yeah, me neither.

Matt Kemp is a shiny golden god.

Andre Ethier (B+) (.311/.383/.463 9hr 1.9 WAR)
Ethier, without question, represented one of the more difficult grades to give out. 30 game hitting streak? Yes, please. .383 OBP? Delicious. While his OPS is nearly 40 points off his 2008 career high, the lower offensive environment this year means that it’s good for a career-best 141 OPS+, so hooray for that. No, he’s not hitting lefties (.242/.282/.368), but he never hits lefties, so that’s not much of a surprise. All in all, it’s been a very solid year from one of the two main offensive threats this club has.

Yet… it feels like something is missing. Prior to his two-homer day yesterday, he’d hit just seven dingers, and his SLG is down for the third year in a row. It’s certainly not enough of a problem to criticize him, hence the good grade, and perhaps yesterday’s outburst was the start of something new. I just can’t help shaking the feeling that is very unpopular among the casual fans who love him so much: Ethier is a very good player, but not a superstar. We’ll need to keep that in mind when his contract is up. I don’t want to get too down on him, though: right now, he’s the second best player on this team, and that in itself is quite valuable.

******

Don’t forget: Matt Kemp is in the Home Run Derby tonight and will be live tweeting @TheRealMattKemp throughout.

0 comments

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Arizona, i.e., the only time anyone ever gave a crap about Hector Gimenez. Or as I said during our midseason recap: I would like to say something witty or insightful about Hector Gimenez, but that infers that I [...]

  2. [...] of which was reflected in his midseason grade in early July: James Loney (C-) (.268/.311/.342 4hr -0.5 [...]

  3. [...] bench role, seeing plenty of playing time at both middle infield positions. As you can see by his midseason review in July, we were more than pleased with his contribution: Last season, Carroll had a .718 OPS and was [...]

  4. [...] He was voted as a starter into the All-Star Game, and he participated in the Home Run Derby. His midseason grade here was predictably giddy: Matt Kemp (A+++) (.313/.398/.584 22hr 27sb 5.7 WAR) I know you come [...]

  5. [...] still, I wasn’t quite sure what to make of his first half: Andre Ethier (B+) (.311/.383/.463 9hr 1.9 WAR) Ethier, without question, represented one of the [...]

  6. remember: follow these tips on how to…

    make money fast online.contrary to the popular notion, making money with a website only requires small capital. gone are the days when you need to understand html or hire web designers to build you a site and pay a hefty price….

  7. support to your ideas or arguments.use of…

    infographicsa blog post is a way to make people understand aspects related to a certain topic. mere words may not suffice in putting forth an idea completely; pictures, maps or graphs can add just that extra gloss required in presenting an…

  8. good content. once bloggers see how amazing…

    and useful your content is, they will come after you.4.) add value to your content. most of the time, guests bloggers write topics that are designed to suffice their needs. when you are a guest blogger, you must ensure that the…

  9. your blog. make your blog visitor friendly;…

    when it is easy to navigate a visitor will always have an easy time hence they will come back again. as a result, you will make money online since the prospective clients are visiting your site.#10 blogging mistake- uninteresting headlines titles…

  10. which indeed is a very special moment….

    on the other hand many mothers are quite unhappy because they tend to put on weight immediately after birth. so the best way forward is to fall under a diet pattern that enables reduction of weight gained during pregnancy. there are…

  11. like the military but people don’t get…

    hired like the military so job networking is critical. contact your buddies and colleagues to see if they know someone who can move their cause forward. there is some preliminary evidence that social networking websites like linkedin.com facilitate job…

  12. well as your own paid for blog.getting…

    ranked on search engines is going to be key to your long term success with your blog. it takes time but it is well worth it when you are sat on a beach and your blog still has traffic flowing to…

  13. you may choose a treatment that is…

    a little more extensive. a qualified dermatologist is the best person to suggest the right treatment, though it’s ultimately up to you what course you want to take. keep reading this article to learn about some post inflammatory hyperpigmentation trea…

  14. of the better items at military surplus…

    stores. online military equipment stores are best, as you can maintain privacy this way. tactical gear can go a long way in survival situations. why do you think the military uses it?it’s always better to get new equipment if you can….

  15. great way for bloggers to build up…

    a large number of targeted readers for almost no cost.one thing that may keep you from jumping right in and cranking out articles to submit to directories is the question of what you should write about.just remember that writing articles is…

  16. Ken Fisher says:

    exposure to your site through those kids…

    could be good for you.)or perhaps you own a shoe store. blog posts which highlight walking and hiking paths in your area would be a good idea. a winery could keep a travelogue about day trips in the region. a pet…

  17. Link! says:

    will receive. this needs precise detailing within…

    a short span of time. if you are a fast typer with good writing talent, needless to say your blogs will capture more attention.the tips stated above are just some basics to help increase your typing skills. you can try out…

  18. are good for the posts on which…

    you are dong it on.comments are what separates a blog from a static web site. leaving comment is a web site traffic generation technique. commenting is both a long term strategy plus a short-term strategy. commenting on blogs is not a…

  19. be “praise allah, it is a miracle”…

    and not simply “it is a miracle.”anyway, this is how i try to depict each of your characters. my job is not to change your story but to aid you in making it more readable for those who also read it….

  20. sure how to take it to the…

    next level and actually begin to write for profit. it’s not as difficult as you might think to go from amateur to professional writer.start by thinking about what type of writing you would want to do if you were writing professionally….

  21. visit us says:

    in mind while writing a blog post.researchafter…

    choosing the topic you want to write on, first thing you need to do is a proper research on that topic over the internet. always keep a pen and a paper handy so that you can note down the important points…

  22. will ultimately crawl this link, it will…

    associate the word light bulb with your site and lead to better search engine rankings for the term light bulb. similarly use different keywords on different blogs. this makes the link look natural.tip v: bookmark pages you have commented onthis is…

  23. you feel you should, or for the…

    money, you need to be a very talented writer to make the blog posts as compelling as they should be. one of my top suggestions to small business owners for pulling more traffic to their website, attracting publicity and getting more…

  24. i’ve written many pillar articles in the…

    last few years and this one stands out to me. personal opinion posts are very engaging and give your readers something to think about while visiting your blog. write blog posts that are controversial. controversy is huge for driving traffic to…

  25. in the affirmative as you read this,…

    you must also be thinking of ways to improve your blog posts and make them interesting. here are some tips to help you enhance the way you present your ideas and thoughts in a blog post.pictures make people noticehave you ever…

  26. forth it is not unusual for him…

    to bring up a certain anxiety he has about someone else playing with his words. i have edited about half of his novel and from the creative side; it is everything you would look for in a good book. even in…

  27. again, engaging with it more and more…

    each time.if you’re just writing a blog because you feel you should, or for the money, you need to be a very talented writer to make the blog posts as compelling as they should be. it’s a problem many blog-owners face.they…

  28. pads says:

    quality contents and you are known as…

    an expert author and writer, webmasters and ezine publishers can pay you to write contents for them and this is a good way to riches.• enriching lives positively: article writing is an easy means of sharing your wisdom, experiences and expertise…

  29. See me says:

    Websites we think you should visit…

    [...]although websites we backlink to below are considerably not related to ours, we feel they are actually worth a go through, so have a look[...]……

  30. article promotion purposes.article marketing continues to be…

    a great way to generate backlinks and traffic if the articles are unique. once again search engines like google are only looking for unique content at this point and will actually penalize article directories which are filled with duplicate content.art…

  31. Titanic says:

    product launches. they are used in forums,…

    on social networking sites like facebook, and even in chat rooms.blog content writing is the ability to Titanic share your knowledge, ideas and questions with others. you can use blogs to write about specific topics and incorporate hyperlinks back to y…

  32. Macbook says:

    sure that your content is rich with…

    useful and funny tips and advice related to the main topic. people like to laugh!5. social bookmarking. here’s the secret weapon. share your blog posts with your facebook fans. encourage them to spread the word! bloggers everywhere are looking for new…

  33. blogger, how are you able to attract…

    visitors to increase blog traffic? there are ways to consider if you want to improve traffic to your blog.•write engaging posts often. updating your blog frequently is one of the first steps in capturing the attention of your audience. but your…

  34. work or not. this significantly helps cut…

    down on costs.online businesses are able to simulate Titanic the performance of other bigger and competitive companies in their market niche. by outsourcing web content writing needs to a team of professional writers, small business are offered a lever…

  35. competitive advantage on the search engines. it…

    also helps in attracting traffic from search engines, build internal backlink, and make sales if you have an affiliate product or services. lastly, it also provides interesting contents to your visitors and subscribers. the quality of a website depends…

  36. car stereo says:

    also, you can put at the end…

    of the article link to some bloggers that wrote on the same theme, but from another perspective. readers love when they find free resources for free.so, let`s summarize what i wrote. when you start to write articles on your blog, you…

  37. side effects of low vitamin d…

    Thanks for your article on this web site. From my own experience, occasionally softening upwards a photograph might provide the digital photographer with a little an inspired flare. Many times however, this soft clouds isn’t just what exactly you had …

  38. Read was interesting, stay in touch……

    [...]please visit the sites we follow, including this one, as it represents our picks from the web[...]……

  39. Online Articles…

    [...]The information mentioned in the article are some of the best available [...]……

  40. about your target audience. after all it’s…

    not likely you will make money writing a blog only you read. (should you figure out that one, please let me know lol)a product or service is a little more complex. there are lots of ways you can make money online….

  41. has taken a hit recently, but you…

    will still get people taking your articles and putting it on their website – thereby giving you hits from these other people’s website. the whole idea of article marketing is to write high quality articles and submit them to the popular…

  42. Nikki Kay says:

    good word processor like word, open office…

    writer, and works etc. check your written content at a plagiarism-checking website like plagiarism.org, plagium.com, and copyscape. formattingselect an appealing font and good font size of your normal text, sub-headings and headings. you can also use h…

  43. pet website says:

    if your company is struggling to win…

    new contracts via the procurement route then examine what you are doing wrong. if you are writing your own tenders and are up against professional pqq and tender writers then this will most likely be the reason. blog advertising is the…

  44. Airsoft says:

    Evike.com…

    Evike | Airsoft Tactical Gear and Apparel…