Conspiracy Theory Wednesday: Will We Ever Truly Be Rid of Frank McCourt?

It’s every Dodger fan’s worst nightmare, even if they haven’t quite considered the possibility yet: what if Frank McCourt was running a long con in order to attempt to keep the team?

When he finally agreed to sell on November 1, we were ecstatic, understandably. If it didn’t quite add up that a career litigator would so abruptly abandon his fight just weeks before his day in court, after years of insisting he’d never sell, we didn’t notice – we were too busy dreaming about white knights who might be interested in purchasing the team.

Yet despite our joy, it’s becoming hard not to notice the inconsistencies in all this that have been piling up over the last few weeks. Despite agreeing with MLB to sell nearly six weeks ago, the filing didn’t make it to bankruptcy court until December 6. We didn’t get concerned, because surely a transaction involving a billion-dollar team could be complicated, and, hey look over there, is that Ned Colletti handing his secretary a backloaded two-year deal? Then, despite giving up all of his Los Angeles-area homes to ex-wife Jamie in their settlement, Frank claimed he had no intention of leaving Los Angeles and actually attended the annual owner’s meetings in Milwaukee, a move that raised eyebrows considering there had to be more than a few people there disgusted at what he’s put the sport through. Besides, even though he had agreed to sell the team, he still had something of an in – the right to keep the parking lots that surround the stadium, thanks to one of his many shady restructurings of the organization.

At the time, Mike DiGiovanna of the LA Times briefly asked why McCourt was choosing to sell:

But after a bruising two-year battle to keep the Dodgers, why not wait a few more weeks to see if he won in court?

“I had personal reasons to make the decision that I’m not at liberty to share at this time,” McCourt said.

As November continued, the story largely shifted to the legal battle between FOX and the Dodgers, as McCourt attempted to persuade the court to allow him to market the club’s television rights immediately, despite the FOX contract clearly stating those rights were exclusive until the end of the 2012 season. McCourt argued that getting a current valuation of those rights would allow for higher bids of the team than if the prospective buyers were uncertain what their worth would be; playing on the bankruptcy court’s sympathy towards making sure creditors get repaid above all other concerns, the court agreed over FOX’s obvious objections. The ruling seemed dubious at best, since even if McCourt was able to secure a higher bid for future television rights, any new owner would not be obligated to abide by that deal, and could simply re-open the bidding again. This is the part that’s most troubling, because it’s not hard to think that media rights could be worth more a year from now, when the team might have a new owner and a whole hell of a lot more positive press than it does right now.

With the ruling in hand, McCourt can proceed in soliciting rights bids while simultaneously working to sell the team… except with purchase bids due by January 13, buyers have reportedly still not seen the “bid book”, a confidential document outlining the Dodger financial state, despite a December 1 report that said the book would go out “next week”. (i.e., last week.)

This all caught the eye of local legend Ross Newhan, now blogging independently, in a December 2 post I linked to last week:

 ”This has been going on more than a month and no one has seen a book, including the top league officials who, I presume, would have to approve it,” one of the sources said. “It makes you wonder.”

What he and others are wondering would provide Oliver Stone with a conspiracy script that would shock Dodger fans.

The question he and othes are asking is this:

“Does McCourt really intend to sell or is he still seeking a way to retain ownership?”

Though Newhan admits the idea is far-fetched, he lays out the path that McCourt could take if this was his goal, and wouldn’t you know it, the first item is “get permission to sell media rights,” a week before that decision occurred.

Fred Roggin of NBC Los Angeles picked up on the scent yesterday (h/t to Philip for the link), and though his piece was laughably titled “exclusive” (presumably by a headline writer who has never heard of Ross Newhan), he backs up the story that buyers are unsure of where this process is taking them:

I’ve talked with a number of prospective buyers who are all perplexed because they don’t have the book with the Dodger financial information.

Here’s the best part, however. Newhan posted his story on December 2, and Roggin chimed in yesterday, December 13. About a month ago, on November 13, I received an email that I admittedly didn’t think much of at the time. (Yes, it’s largely because half of it was written in caps, and I’m a snob like that.) It’s from a reader who will remain anonymous, in response to Bill Shaikin’s story about McCourt attempting to convince the court to let him sell the media rights, and he may have been the only one to see all of this from the very beginning:

WHAT MCCOURT IS TRYING TO GET AWAY WITH:  He is still trying to sell the tv rights (may the judge save us by refusing to order another corporation, Fox, to give up their negotiated privilege not to do so under duress) so when, according to McCourt’s scheme, the tv deal is negotiated by Blackstone (McCourt) sometime this winter, McCOURT CAN HALT THE SALE OF THE TEAM, WITH THE AGREEMENT IN HAND TO RECEIVE THE FUNDS TO PAY OFF THE CREDITORS, GET THE DODGERS OUT OF BANKRUPTCY AND KEEP THE TEAM.  THAT’S WHAT HE’S TRYING TO PULL HERE, BILL, and no journalist, let alone the braindead octogenarians running MLB, gets that.

What does Fox get out of it? A deal with McCourt, a cheap deal for them, not the blockbuster the next owner would realize from HIS negotiated sale of the rights when the bidding is open to Time-Warner after next November. Fox is currently the only entity ostensibly refusing to go along with McCourt’s request—if they DID agree, it would be OBVIOUS there’s something big in it for them, a MUCH smaller rights fee to pay—so they’re pretending to fight it. When the judge is ready in 2 1/2 weeks to hear their reasons for going against a sale of the tv rights now, all they have to do is show up in court and announce they’re throwing in the towel on the “fight”. Since MLB has already monumentally stupidly agreed to let McCourt have his tv rights sale now, as quid pro quo for agreeing to sell the Dodgers, there will be no one to object to giving McCourt the tv sale now, and the rest of the plan McCourt and Fox have hatched will extend Fox’s telecasts of the Dodgers forever at a bargain rate, and McCourt will keep the Dodgers as a result.

I won’t pretend there’s not a bit of “tin foil hat” going on in there, because clearly this entire conversation is one big conspiracy theory that might be way, way off base. Still, there’s enough smoke there to not dismiss this outright. MLB did agree not to oppose the sale of the broadcast rights, as they otherwise would have, in order to finally get McCourt to agree to sell. And FOX and Time Warner, who have had rights fees wars for years across the country, are, by all indications, gearing up for a massive war over Southern California sports telecasts.

While allowing the two corporate giants to fight over the Dodgers would surely increase the ultimate payoff, if McCourt’s goal is simply to get enough to cover his debts, pay off his ex-wife, and get the team out of bankruptcy, then perhaps he’s less interested in “every last penny” as he would be in “as much as I can get, as soon as I can get” – and not only are the Dodgers and FOX supposedly still negotiating despite the court ruling, McCourt tried something similar in the past, attempting to sell the future rights to FOX for what was considered below market value in order to see an immediate influx. In addition, it’s not like he hasn’t previously been in bed with FOX on prior loans anyway. Besides, if the latest reports are true which indicate that the Dodgers are contractually restricted from creating a new regional network with Time Warner, ESPN, or Comcast are true – i.e., all the big players who aren’t FOX – then that’s just a further incentive to stick with FOX. (That’s a battle which has yet to play out in court, though.)

But it doesn’t have to be FOX. That might be the ultimate goal of getting the court to open up the bidding, to show FOX that even if McCourt would prefer to stick with them, he’s no longer obligated to. Otherwise, FOX would just wait out the ownership transfer and still likely have time to speak exclusively with the new boss before their rights deal expired. Now, they have motivation to strike a deal before the rights get shopped around. So as the theory goes, McCourt could come to an agreement with FOX or someone else on a long-term rights deal, one that would be a step up from what the Dodgers currently get yet still likely below what the results of an all-out bidding war could be, and all of a sudden McCourt could go back to the bankruptcy court and say, “my house is in order, I have the money to pay off my ex-wife, all of my creditors, and operate the team. Throw out the agreement with MLB.”

And that’s what the big, big sticking point in all this is. McCourt has that agreement with Major League Baseball, and another with his ex-wife. By April 30, he has to both sell the team and pay Jamie about $130 million. Even if there’s a hint of truth to any of this, MLB still has the right to approve the new television contract, and it goes without saying that they would never, ever allow McCourt to sign such a deal and collect even a penny of the new earnings. This would set up yet another massive court fight, one bigger than any we’ve seen thus far, and while it may seem unlikely that McCourt and his legal team could convince the court to throw out the agreement with MLB, no one thought he’d be able to convince them to open up the television rights either – the last few legal arguments have all gone Frank’s way.

If this whole idea wasn’t so deliciously evil – and I’m talking head-thrown-back, maniacal-cackling, lighting-a-cigar-with-a-game-worn-Jackie-Robinson-uniform evil – it’d be brilliant. Now, as I’ve been reminded of by a reader lately (and quite correctly so), I am not a lawyer. I’m far more comfortable discussing wOBAs than CPAs, and when I started this blog over four years ago I never dreamed this would be the sort of thing we’d be spending our time on, so it’s eminently possible that I’m not reading the tea leaves correctly on all this.

So maybe this is much ado about nothing. Maybe I spent my Wednesday morning linking to a dozen Bill Shaikin articles simply because of a crazy, alien-abduction-sounding theory, because I have to admit, this whole thing sounds ludicrous enough that part of me is reluctant to even hit ‘publish’ on the post.

But maybe, just maybe, Frank McCourt is a slimy, court-manipulating evil genius who’ll stop at nothing to get what he wants and attempt to rebuild his name. I just don’t want to say we never saw it coming, and there’s been enough oddities since the deal was announced to wonder just what’s really going on.

0 comments

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Conspiracy Theory Wednesday: Will We Ever Truly Be Rid of Frank … We didn't get concerned, because surely a transaction involving a billion-dollar team could be complicated, and, hey look over there, is that Ned Colletti handing his secretary a backloaded two-year deal? Then, despite giving up . The ruling seemed dubious at best, since even if McCourt was able to secure a higher bid for future television rights, any new owner would not be obligated to abide by that deal, and could simply re-open the bidding again. This is the part . [...]

  2. [...] MSTI: Mike Petriello addresses the elephant in the room: Frank McCourt remaining as owner. [...]

  3. [...] stats actually mean something, and is probably even less likely than the idea that Frank McCourt could try to hang onto the team, though if a portly first baseman should happen to land in the Dodgers’ laps on a [...]

  4. [...] anything he says? It’s massive distrust like that which makes hysterical conspiracy theories like this one actually seem viable. While the idea put forward there that McCourt might actually just be playing [...]

  5. google are only looking for unique content…

    at this point and will actually penalize article directories which are filled with duplicate content.article writing does take time since most directories are looking for articles about 400 words or longer. as a writer you can expect to make around $5…

  6. this with your site. remember you can…

    always edit your blog, and change things around, nothing is set in stone. once you start a blog keep all the posts a consistent style, this will keep the blog looking professional and organised.5. pictures and videos, not too much or…

  7. way to stop the reader from losing…

    interest during a tricky patch of technical detail, or something of an unclear point.finally, and most importantly, enjoy writing the blog. if someone enjoys writing a blog, it shows in everything. the quality improves, and readers will come back again…

  8. know that first you should order about…

    5-7 copies from the company and see what happens. each copy they will deliver to you must be written according to the quality level they had promised. it must pass plagiarism test and quality assurance test, so hire a professional to…

  9. nice company says:

    post or by promoting a product your…

    affiliated with. books, software, websites, courses and any kind of resource can be topics for an effective review post. interview someone: leverage the success and popularity of people in your niche or industry by interviewing them. approach with a si…

  10. add just that extra gloss required in…

    presenting an idea. you can combine infographics or information graphics in your blog post and enhance the readability of your blogs.when you create content that others read, comprehend and assimilate thoughts about, it becomes necessary to present the…

  11. my website says:

    of content, it is smarter not to…

    label yourself as a blog writer. blog writing is just one of the many types of writing that you are capable of producing. you write content. your content will carry you very far if it is well written, insightful, interesting and…

  12. its unedited form it is one of…

    those books that you just do not want to put down.from the technical side, it sucks. it contains spelling, grammatical, and time line errors. at times, he writes things about a character without any important background information or context. in its…

  13. mean.2. spell check and proof- read your…

    work after you have finished. a blog with loads of spelling mistakes and grammar issues will not get loads of people returning, a spell checked blog looks and fells more professional and will get more people coming back. depending on what…

  14. Links says:

    product is with a blog. there are…

    many blogging platforms out there, and perhaps the 2 most popular ones are blogger and wordpress. many people use these 2 blogging platforms, and you can use them also for your business too.personally, if you’re a beginner, you should start off…

  15. email, text message, and online chat. they…

    maintain long-distance conversations this way, writing back as quickly as possible. this, however, can be disrupting their ability to do well in writing. when they write papers, they may slip into their “text-talk,” forget to spell out specific words…

  16. the reader will suggest it to their…

    friends. if the article is on an article directory like ezinearticles.com then the reader may be one of many looking for content to put on their own site.the more sites your article goes on the better. article directories insist in their…

  17. the start of most projects, and blogs…

    are no exception to this, we often have a great deal of enthusiasm, and plan to do so much every day to keep the writing and content fresh and updated.however, as time progresses, that enthusiasm slowly dies, and we do less…

  18. click here says:

    know how to reach your web page.social…

    bookmarkingsocial bookmarking is a way of putting a tag on the blog proclaiming that it is a great one. this attracts the attention of other visitors who visit the social bookmarking site and choose your bookmarked link. with millions of visitors,…

  19. remember to keep our opinions to ourselves,…

    unless asked for by our client. our opinions come from our own emotional biases and we must detach when writing for others. we must not allow ourselves to become emotionally biased as this may cause animosity.r is for respect: this entails…

  20. always written for the target audiences and…

    the best writing comes when the writer is relaxed and not stressed either. if the environment is peaceful and noiseless, it will be very conducive to such article writing.original and high quality contents matter the mostprospective writer should reali…

  21. more info says:

    insight about why you believe this prediction…

    may be correct. you can create a lot of discussion by using this style of posting.write a serieslet’s say you have a lot to write about and you are an expert on a particular subject. you can break your posts down…

  22. only 5% of bloggers are earning big…

    bucks. but you can also earn big bucks by blogging in the great blog sites. if you already have your own blog, you can visit the best blog sites such as reviewme, payperpost, sponsoredreview, blogitive and blogsvertise.reviewme acts just like a…

  23. the other options can do for you…

    over time. the great thing with a wordpress blog is you can either access and work on your blog from wordpress directly or you can host it yourself. you can set yourself up with a hosting site and from that site…

  24. should be included.using these steps should help…

    you to prepare your blog post for maximum leverage.but do you know that there are a few more things that you should do to compete for first page rankings.the two other key factors for how to do a blog post that…

  25. like a newspaper. this is the secret…

    to becoming a famous expert in blogging. when you do this you will gain a lot of loyal readers. you should try to update your blogging website on a daily basis if you can. this is pretty easy to do. web…

  26. strong today – check out justin hall’s…

    blog.blogs are an incredible testament to the power of the world wide web. everything from the comments we make to the people we friend on facebook becomes molded in the web, as a footprint impression in concrete, it can only be…

  27. Macbook says:

    traffic.visit this page to learn why you…

    shouldn’t rely on online marketing to build your business. as a blog writer you may have experienced how hard it is to always get fresh idea for writing a blog. at least there are two tools that you can use for…

  28. increases in visibility. when more people can…

    see your blog, traffic definitely improves. you can make your blog seo friendly by using keyword rich content, regularly updating the blog with new content and encouraging posts and comments. if you are looking for a one stop solution for all…

  29. a lot more than creativity to run…

    an innovation laboratory. in fact a creative idea for a corporation could easily fail if it’s not coordinated during the implementation phase with other parts of the company.this is well-known and there are lots of books on this topic, but in…

  30. “content copiers”.more serious are people that buy…

    content to post on the internet!!!are you aware that you can now hire a firm to write articles for you along with inserting your organization information source and author bio?this strategy will be seriously unfortunate for you because i will almost…

  31. past but mostly uses fictional characters and…

    events. historical fiction is seen in novels, plays, magazines, television and art. writers today are blessed with opportunities to check historical facts before writing a historical fiction book; they can read informative books, journals, and internet…

  32. the articles should be informative, optimized, and…

    thoroughly updated so that the viewer is not diverted instead of remaining attracted to the website he or she is viewing.steps for finding the best article writing services onlineonline search is different from the traditional brick and concrete market…

  33. way all the time.the title is the…

    only thing that matters. i know, that’s a pretty bold statement, but it’s pretty important. you see, i’ve seen many bloggers get great results just because their title was above and beyond what most people would write. make sure that it…

  34. child play says:

    new stuff on your post.. hi… that…

    was great stuff.. i really like this subject. could you tell me more… i would love to explore. thanks for taking the time to discuss this, i feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. if possible, as…

  35. you can because the more questions you…

    will get the more articles you will write. in order to find forums, you will need to open google and search for a term such as ”weight loss forums.”once you have found at least 5 forums, you will need to follow…