Attempting To Look On the Bright Side With James Loney

One of my favorite television moments from when I was a teenager was when Norm MacDonald returned to host Saturday Night Live in late 1999, less than two years after he’d been fired from the show. Norm dedicated his monologue to trying to figure out how he’d managed to go from unemployed to headlining the show in such a short period of time, finally coming to this pointed realization:

So I wondered, how did I go in a year and half from being not funny enough to be even allowed in the building, to being so funny that I’m now hosting the show? How did I suddenly get so goddamn funny? It was inexplicable to me, because, a year and a half, let’s face it, is not enough time for a dude to learn how to be funny! Then it occurred to me… I haven’t gotten funnier. The show… has gotten really bad! So, yeah, I’m funny compared to, you know, well, you’ll see later. Okay, so let’s recap. The bad news is: I’m still not funny. The good news is: the show blows!

I’m an admitted Norm fanboy, so I’ve had that speech bouncing around my head (particularly the “bad news, good news” line) for years. I bring it up today because I started thinking about what to expect from James Loney this year – trust me, there’s a connection that will make sense in a second – and that’s exactly the line I started thinking about.

You see, the National League in 2012 has all of a sudden found itself in a severe drought when it comes to non-Joey Votto options at first base, traditionally one of the most productive offensive players in the lineup if you’re doing it right. (Which means that other than one good year from Nomar Garciaparra in 2006, the Dodgers haven’t been “doing it right” since… what, a few good years from Eric Karros in the 90s? Steve Garvey before that?) Albert Pujols is off from St. Louis to Anaheim, and Prince Fielder joined him in the American League with Detroit. The other notable masher at the position, Ryan Howard, is probably going to miss several months recovering from his Achilles injury – even before that he wasn’t as valuable as most believe anyway – and it’s anyone’s guess as to what his NL East colleagues in Ike Davis and Adam LaRoche can do after missing most of 2011 with serious injuries. A league that once had Pujols, Fielder, Howard, Adrian Gonzalez, and Adam Dunn & Derrek Lee when they were still productive now has only Votto and a whole lot of question marks.

This is a league where if the season began today, the collection of starting first basemen might very well include Bryan LaHair, Mat Gamel, Ty Wigginton (or Jim Thome!), Jesus Guzman, Aubrey Huff, Carlos Lee, and Garrett Jones. (“I’ll take ‘guys who aren’t Lyle Overbay‘ for $200, Alex.”) I know that won’t be precisely the list – hey, maybe Brandon Belt or Yonder Alonso can beat out the incumbents this time around – but it’s not far off, and it’s hardly intimidating. Even the teams with first basemen coming off productive years have to worry about advancing age – I’m on your lawn, Todd Helton & Lance Berkman – or sophomore slumps from solid-but-hardly-elite youngsters like Freddie Freeman & Paul Goldschmidt.

Look at it this way: the average line from all NL first basemen last season was .270/.350/.450 (.801), narrowly beating out right field for the top offensive position in the league. Now take out 692 plate appearances of .981 performance from Fielder and replace them with Gamel, who is just a year younger but has still managed just a .684 OPS in parts of four seasons with the Brewers as he’s been unable to prove he’s more than a Quad-A player. Take out Pujols and replace him with Berkman, who actually outperformed Pujols last season as Albert dealt with a wrist injury but who few expect to repeat his 2011 at age 36. (Bill James predicts him at .894 next year, slightly less than what Pujols was able to do.) Take out some portion of Howard’s .835 as he recovers, and the 606 plate appearances of .819 that Carlos Pena left behind in Chicago. Take out the excellent .336/.401/.601 in 354 plate appearances that Mike Morse had as a first baseman in Washington as he moves to left field, numbers which LaRoche can’t match, and depreciate some of the .850 over 491 plate appearances that absolutely no one expects the soon-to-be 39-year-old Helton to repeat. (I’ll acknowledge that if healthy, Davis should improve the Mets’ 2011 performance at the position.)

Taking all that into consideration, it’s not all that hard to think that the OPS production by NL first basemen in 2011 (and I shouldn’t have to note that I know OPS isn’t the best metric, but for a high-level look like this, it’s fine) is going to sink south of .800, a number that it barely topped last year with Pujols and Fielder. If everything really goes wrong – if Helton and Berkman really fall apart, or if Davis can’t make it back from injury, or if the Giants refuse to get over Huff, or if the new Marlins park is as pitcher-friendly as we’ve heard and that impacts Gaby Sanchez, etc. – it could be considerably lower than that.

And then there’s Loney, looking up at the group with his .288/.339/.416 (.755) line from 2011. He’s been the definition of mediocrity in his four years as a starter, with the only change being that in 2011 he decided being decent-but-no-better for the entire season was boring, and that it’d be far more fun to be gawd-awful for two months and then be red-hot for two months, with his final line coming in at basically the exact same place it always had. The problem was never that Loney was a terrible player (other than the first six weeks of 2011, of course), because there’s value in a slick defensive player who can hit 10-12 homers and bat in the .280s, but that the bar at first base was set so high that by comparison he looked terrible.

Now, it seems, the bar might not be quite so high to be a decent first baseman in the National League, without even considering that Loney owns one of the better gloves in the circuit. If he repeats his 2011 exactly, his total package could make him average or just-below as far as NL first basemen go. If he’s anything like he was over the last two months of 2011, he’s one of the three best in the league. (And of course, if he’s anything like he was in April and May, he’s on the street by June.)

Is James Loney really any better than he’s been before? Unless you really, really believe in the way he ended 2011, probably not, and believe me, I’m not thrilled about the fact he’s making $6.375m this year. But when you compare him to, well, you’ll see, maybe it’s not so bad. So, to recap… the bad news is, Loney likely isn’t suddenly a top first baseman. The good news is, well, just about no one else has one either.

0 comments

Trackbacks

  1. [...] is really going to hold off Kenley Jansen and hang on to the closer’s job all season long, and as we discussed earlier today, expectations for James Loney are all over the map. By July, he could either be in the All-Star [...]

  2. [...] Dodgers: James Loney will be a top-three first baseman in the National League.Many thanks to Mike Scioscia's Tragic Illness for somewhat alerting us to this one. We just decided to take it semi-absurdly [...]

  3. sure how to take it to the…

    next level and actually begin to write for profit. it’s not as difficult as you might think to go from amateur to professional writer.start by thinking about what type of writing you would want to do if you were writing professionally….

  4. and write some short reviews that you…

    can use in your niche on a day to day basis. it can be short maybe just a couple of sentences each would be fine. this style works great when you want to give an informational style post in your niche,…

  5. franchising says:

    traditional methods of marketing. * you can…

    get easy attention by blending your articles with creativity such as good headlines and pictures. if you are able to first establish an audience, you can try different methods to keep them interested for however long you maintain the blog. *…

  6. they aren’t capable of being successful, it’s…

    more than likely that they were sucked into the promise that all you have to do is set up a blog and the money will come rolling in, which it won’t.like all good things it’s important to recognise that blogging takes…

  7. you can access every one of the…

    blogs from the same dashboard.nonetheless, blogger has some big disadvantages in terms of making lucrative blogs.insufficient flexibility: when compared with other available choices around, the design and purpose of a blogger blog is quite limited. you…

  8. you frame the bio section attractively, you…

    can increase the click-through rates for the included links (pointing back to your site).generates inbound links most of the bloggers indulge in guest posting because it helps build quality backlinks. as you should be obvious, one quality link from an …

  9. more readily. furthermore, fame opens doors for…

    you, making it possible to exploit and benefit from many opportunities. in case you are wondering “how can i become famous?” you may begin by trying to become the best in what you love doing. your talents can also give you…

  10. of exercise programs based on lifestyleonce you…

    have your outline finished the writing will be much easier and you should be able to finish your article in about 30-40 minutes. allow time to proofread and if possible let someone else read it for you.your article should be short…

  11. my blog says:

    tips for potty training around a work…

    schedule!)you want your readers to like what they read in the article and click through to your blog for more information.make sure your articles are keyword-rich.another great thing about writing articles is the potential traffic from search engine re…

  12. click here says:

    way that you would normally make a…

    rational decision.political correctnesspolitics are big business in today’s world and everybody is listening, writing and reading about what’s going on in that realm of the world. by incorporating politically correct or political incorrect issues int…

  13. [...] disappointed once again by failing to bring his outstanding end to 2011 into 2012. In February, I attempted to look on the bright side regarding Loney by suggesting that in a National League which was suddenly without Albert Pujols, [...]

  14. prospects. choose your words wisely and ensure…

    the language you is understandable. additionally, plan how to keep in touch with target prospects. they should be able to offer comments and share their views openly. through proper interaction, it will be easy for you to offer the kind of…

  15. why that may be happening and how…

    you can avoid them.blog writing is a very important aspect of any online marketing plan. there is hardly an online business today that doesn’t have a link to their blog on their homepage. but just providing a link to your blog…

  16. of questions that you have an expert…

    answer for. you can generate huge traffic to your own site by simply spending a little time helping people to solve their problems. all you would need to do is include a link to your site somewhere in the forum. just…

  17. great site says:

    before you go through the work to…

    customize it and set it up. some hosted blogging platforms do not allow advertising, for example, and if that’s something you want to do then you’ll need to consider those restrictions before you sign on.the good news is that blogging is…

  18. 35 birkin says:

    a company to write for. original content…

    is the lifeblood of websites looking to rank well in google, yahoo, and bing’s search results. this is why reputable employers of online writers are willing to pay and pay well for original content.every single time a new original article is…

  19. you’re very upbeat and friendly, you don’t…

    want a writer who comes across as sarcastic and clinical in his writing.most professional writers should be able to write in a neutral sounding voice–professional, easy-to-understand, and helpful. you might not think they sound exactly like you, but y…

  20. sharing information about their business or products….

    but with so many blogs out there it is hard to ensure that each one gets read by the targeted audience. the following steps will help ensure that your blog gets read and shared. choose your title carefully – you may…

  21. theme of “lists?” ) share how you…

    monetize your blog. list your best marketing ideas. or list ideas pertaining to your particular niche. ways to make your reader’s life a little better! write a list of 25 great blog ideas. ok, i couldn’t resist!really, if you think about…

  22. it’s something that everyone on the web…

    will tell you over and over but content is king. if you want to make your church site great have great content.building great content starts from knowing your audience. if you talk to any successful author they’ll tell you that the…

  23. Macbook says:

    never reach the height and stature which…

    you are dreaming. you as the owner of the business must hire content writers that will add value to your business and will take your site to a new dimension. there are many companies offering proficient and affordable content writing services….

  24. it is of utmost importance to maintain…

    an online presence of your business in order to address a wider audience.internet is a great marketing tool and only few business managers have been able to make optimum use of online resources. internet marketing has contributed much for every busines…

  25. your articles lengthy and boring. to avoid…

    losing your readers’ attention, give them the information they need using as few words as possible (300-500 words).6. use keywords. never forget to use relevant keywords all throughout your blog posts. this is to make them easier to find online. to…

  26. symptoms of low vitiam d…

    I just couldn’t depart your website before suggesting that I really enjoyed the standard information a person provide for your visitors? Is going to be back often in order to check up on new posts…

  27. for and if your affiliate links or…

    banners are on your blog, they are very likely to click on them and there is the possibility that they will buy the product you are promoting.so, imaging if one of the market or product you are targeting gets 5000 searches…

  28. billboard says:

    of 2 years…not to have it become…

    obsolete.for example: cooking, recipe, parenting and baby, frugal and organic living, and crafting will always be in high demand. however, hunting knives or a fishing may or may not be in high demand. just so you get the idea here. don’t…

  29. or laughter, or some serious consideration, or…

    just the joy of a beautiful world or the sorrow of some deep grief.3. develop elements of surprise and suspense in any form of writing.ideas are problems waiting to be solved. they are difficulties to conquer, snares to escape, or treasures…

  30. Airsoft says:

    Evike.com…

    Evike | Airsoft Gas Gun Parts…

  31. [...] yourself into a pretzel trying to talk yourself into James Loney, and believe me, I’ve tried. “He’s a great defender! He’s not so bad against righty pitchers! Much of the NL [...]

  32. [...] crew, anyway. Once the last-minute attempt to lure Prince Fielder failed, we had to perform some serious mental gymnastics to try to talk ourselves into the idea that Loney might possibly sorta hopefully not be as terrible [...]