Are the Dodgers Going To Have the Weakest Catching Situation in Baseball?

All of us love A.J. Ellis around here. How can you not? He’s the kind of guy you always root for, because after having been in the minors for nine seasons (including four in a row at Triple-A) and seeing small stints with the big club in every year since 2008, he’s finally positioned to be a big-league starter for the first time in 2012 at age 31. It’s the kind of story we can all relate to, and it helps that when he’s actually seen playing time late in the year over the last two seasons, he’s been excellent, putting up a .342/.444/.461 line over 92 September/October plate appearances since 2010. Even his style works, because on a team that has had far too many OBP black holes in recent years, getting on base is exactly his strength, along with positive reviews of his pitcher handling. And selfishly, I’ll admit that any ballplayer who not only has a Twitter account but is interesting with it and follows me, Jon Weisman, and Eric Stephen gets an additional one billion coolness points.

Few of us like Matt Treanor. He’s old. He can’t hit, at all, even a little. That’s usually fine from a backup backstop, because you’re rarely expecting much from the position other than to be a capable defender, but Treanor grades out poorly there as well, not even as good as Rod Barajas was. You don’t ever want to get too agitated over a one-year, small-money commitment to a player who really isn’t going to make much of a difference, but Treanor was never good, and when he turns 36 in two weeks he’s not going to start getting any better. He exists. I’m not sure why.

None of us are really sure what to make of Tim Federowicz. You try not to unfairly denigrate him simply because he was included in one of the most shocking and unpopular Dodger trades in years, because he had nothing to do with that, and his defense is supposedly excellent. However, I’ve yet to see anyone outside the Dodger front office who thinks he can hit enough to be a big-league starter, and if he isn’t more than a backup, then why did you trade Trayvon Robinson for him anyway? Well, there I go again, busting him for a trade he didn’t ask for. Kevin Goldstein ranked him as the 13th best Dodger prospect recently at Baseball Prospectus, and being one spot ahead of Ethan Martin and four below Alex Castellanos isn’t exactly high praise. Maybe he’ll improve his hitting skills, but we won’t find that out this year in Albuquerque; remember, playing in the PCL once made Terry Tiffee look like a stud.

Taken as a whole, the top three Dodger catchers are questionable at best. We like Ellis and are optimistic about him, but can his great-eye, zero-power ways stop pitchers from throwing nothing but strikes, and how many guys are really impact players when they don’t get their first real shots until 31? Is Treanor going to be really bad or just very bad? And is Federowicz really the catcher of the future, or just someone we say nice things about regarding his defense while we hope Gorman Erickson pans out? Or Pratt Maynard? Or someone we don’t even know about yet?

One scout asked BP‘s John Perrotto just that:

“I don’t understand what the Dodgers are doing here. These guys are both number-two catchers, and I can’t imagine either one of them starting 100 games. Maybe they think (rookie Tim) Fedorowicz [sic] will be the answer at some point in the season, but I wasn’t all that impressed with what I saw of him last September. This has to be the weakest catching situation in the major leagues.”

The weakest catching situation in the major leagues. Well, I thought, that seems kind of harsh, but to outsiders who don’t have as much of a soft spot for Ellis as we do, I suppose I can see where they’re coming from. On the other hand, outside of a few teams, catching is a black hole across the sport. But the weakest? Well, I couldn’t let that go by without trying to figure out if that’s true. Of course, there’s no black and white way to solidly identify that, because you can’t just go by 2011 stats; situations have changed, players have moved, players have aged.

Besides, we’re not interested in what happened in 2011, we’re trying to project what might happen in 2012, so for that, I went to BP‘s PECOTA spreadsheet, the most recent version of which was posted on Tuesday. In order to weed out minor leaguers and others who may skew the data, I referenced MLBDepthCharts.com to identify the likely top two catchers for each team in 2012, with some small changes to their guesses. By combining BP‘s WARP score (their variation of WAR) for each club’s top two backstops, we have a quick-and-dirty way of looking at the value of each team’s 2012 backstop duo.

So are the Dodgers the worst? Well, not exactly…

Team / Total WARP / Top Two
1. MIN 5.8 Joe Mauer, Ryan Doumit
2t. CLE 4.6 Carlos Santana, Lou Marson
2t. ATL 4.6 Brian McCann, David Ross
4. TEX 4.2 Mike Napoli, Yorvit Torrealba
5. STL 3.4 Yadier Molina, Bryan Anderson


25. LAN 1.2 A.J. Ellis, Matt Treanor
26. PIT 1.1 Rod Barajas, Michael McKenry
27. SEA 0.8 Miguel Olivo, John Jaso
28. KCA 0.7 Salvador Perez, Brayan Pena
29. HOU 0.6 Chris Snyder, Humberto Quintero
30. TBA -0.1 Jose Lobaton, Jose Molina

So according to PECOTA, the Dodgers might have merely the sixth-worst catching group in the game. Take that, nameless scout! Of course, this is loaded with caveats, because even if PECOTA was an exact science (which it’s not), a difference in 0.2 points of WARP is so insignificant that it’s hardly worth noting, so think of this more as being “in the bottom group”. Still, expect some fluctuation there. If the Mariners really do play Jesus Montero regularly behind the plate, his bat alone will vault Seattle out of this group, and I’m somewhat surprised to see the Royals ranking so low, considering that Perez was impressive as a 21-year-old in the bigs last season. Not the Astros, though. Good lord, are the Astros going to be bad.

Most importantly, all of this is tied up in Ellis. Unlike most of the other clubs where the two catchers combine their value to reach the total WARP, this represents Ellis at 1.2 and Treanor (and Federowicz, for that matter) at 0.0. I’m cautiously optimistic that Ellis can keep his OBP high enough that along with his plus defense his near-total lack of power won’t prevent him from being a solid starter, or at least solid enough to get the Dodgers through the season and guarantee him a big-league career that could last for several more years. But if he can’t, or if he gets injured, there’s nothing behind him to step in. And you remember what shortstop looked like when Rafael Furcal got hurt in 2008, right?

0 comments

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Yeager hit .228/.298/.355 over his career, which makes him basically the perfect person to work the current group of catchers… or lead an interstellar [...]

  2. The Best Cat Suits For Women…

    [...]following are a few hyper-links to online sites I always link to for the fact we believe they will be definitely worth visiting[...]…

  3. have people subscribe via your rss feeda…

    news reader is a program that automatically updates your google, yahoo, or msn feed. you can easily get news readers onto your blog by going to a site called feedburner. this is a great site to be on, and it will…

  4. start by identifying a keyword that is…

    high demand but low competition.the importance of finding the right keyword is to accurately identify the target group you are trying to reach. this is the first step because if you misidentify your keyword your content won’t get seen by the…

  5. a guest post for them. guest posts…

    are a great way to get traffic to your blog, as you’ll be able to share in the popularity of that blog even for a short while.there are also many powerful blogging communities where you can syndicate your content, make new…

  6. good article says:

    writers who overwrite often lose their readers…

    before the end, or at least send their readers into agonies of groaning, along with the occasional laugh in the wrong place.despite everything your high school english teacher may have taught you, or you misunderstood in her class, using big words…

  7. click here says:

    traffic and visitors so that you can…

    establish your blog as being a credible site within your niche. for those who have a popular blog and are having a difficulty finding time, an automatic blog writer could be just the answer that they were looking for. having a…

  8. this link says:

    break it up with white space, sub…

    headers and bullet lists. they want answers fast so don’t drag it out.if you are passionate about the topic you write on, the readers will feel it in your articles. any time you get an idea for a new article topic,…

  9. that in fact, you are the expert…

    and you have the answers!use numbersusing numbers in headlines almost always works to attract attention from readers. make sure that you vary it up so that not every one of your headlines sounds the same. when you incorporate numbers, such as…

  10. website says:

    when women still experience symptoms even during…

    the post menopausal stage. the main reason behind this would be the hormonal changes that take place during the said stage. during this stage, estrogen and progesterone levels inside the body decrease, which causes a number of symptoms to occur. on…

  11. english composition courses, or to test into…

    more advanced courses. these tests that are given to students are generally composed of an essay section and a multiple choice section as well. placement exams such as these are designed to make sure each student is where he or she…

  12. my website says:

    commentators on your blog is also a…

    good move. it encourages visitors to comment on your blog to gain the top positions.so, start following the above simple tips and you will definitely see the difference. are you happy with the amount of traffic you’re currently getting to your…

  13. according to the search engine” as it…

    can be easily crawled. basically, it is good to follow google web master guidelines. there are certain on-page factors that should be considered while designing web site. these area. titleb. h1,h2, h3 tagsc. descriptiond. image optimizatione. no broken…

  14. version. most smart phones these days can…

    view normal websites well and the new version of wordpress seems to adapt automatically when viewed in phones, however saying that. wp touch makes your site look a lot better and arranges your posts into an easier to read list. install,…

  15. in mind, you will never run out…

    of fresh ideas for your content.fierce competitionanother good reason not to limit yourself when it comes to online writing is that you will have an easier time finding your hook, which will allow you to stand out and beat the pants…

  16. that you’re passionate about. remain motivated and…

    something will come out of all of your hard work. life has inspired your words and now it’s time to share what you’ve learned with others and generations to come. choosing a good writing service is often difficult to do. many…

  17. itself once in a while. writing with…

    variety, flair and innovation will always set you ahead of the pack and put you well on your way to catapulting your blog post writing to the next level. so you’ve got your new blog now and you’ve found a great…

  18. or tweet. or blog.whatever information celebrities like…

    jamie oliver and posh spice may divulge, having this information allows the public and media to have something to spread to other people. for the media and paparazzi, it makes their jobs easier because they do not have to follow these…

  19. to your posts as that will attract…

    more attention, especially if they are captivating.8. occasionally post good videos or audios as those have much greater impact.9. get on board with the new pages timeline as you can put links in the little boxed under the main header and…

  20. know the path that you want the…

    reader to take when you are formatting your blog posts. do you want them to read another post? do you want them to go to your capture page? do you want them to subscribe to your rss feed? what do you…

  21. to update it everyday just like you…

    would a diary. you will eventually develop a following of readers, and they will come back to your site everyday for more of your valuable information.now readers won’t just appear out of nowhere. you have to implement marketing strategies to get…

  22. jelly birkin says:

    well but remember there are specific steps…

    you need to take and plan how you can get the most out of the time you put in otherwise you can achieve your goals but still fail.as a blogger you will face a lot of challenges and will have to…

  23. is; or you sell your business online…

    then you are already an internet marketer.the advantage of marketing online is that there is a wide reach of customers because it is showed globally and the startup cost is low.internet marketing before was just a way to share information to…

  24. is to assist your kids to focus…

    on the content. start building their confidence and encourage them to write more. don’t focus on their mistakes.is it hard to get the kids to write simple articles? not at all! what do you do when your boss says you don’t…

  25. any case the writer can make good…

    only by following the guidelines issues. resources that are used by the companies for prospective as well as existing members include -• article writing guidelines; • general guidelines for writing articles; • editorial guidelines; and …

  26. reader. scribe seo encourages you to have…

    at least one relevant link near the top of your post. so what is the right answer. i typically think 1 per hundred words works well. it shows the post is well connected without being overwhelming. when you add a link,…

  27. a hundred page essay that is badly…

    written. write what you would read, if you only write a blog to make money then you won’t go far you will give up before you start making some real money.1. to write good content you need to have patience and…

  28. pads says:

    always looking for websites from which they…

    can learn new things especially if they are trying to find out more about certain commodities and/or services.writing authoritative articles is not just a great way to plug your products or services but will also help you build authority and thought-le…

  29. from them at all, unless they want…

    to publish your work. you’ll also find publishers who require you to submit a query letter and a synopsis first. then, if it appeals to them, they’ll ask you to send the manuscript.here’s a little heads up about manuscripts and submissions:**never…

  30. Titanic says:

    traffic quickly. when this does not happen,…

    they become impatient and frustrated and finally give up without even giving their blog a second chance.patience Titanic in blogging pays. when you start blogging you need to keep to it. remember that consistence, interesting and relevant posts will de…

  31. one? okay. this is a really loaded…

    question. you’ll have to consider your budget and the type of quality as well as the length of your project. there are the all too popular bidding sites that you can post your project on and get “bids” from a million…

  32. Macbook says:

    on the other hand, a bad title…

    will turn away clients. for this reason, it is important to get a good and impressive title for all your posts to make them seo friendly.keep your posts shortthere is a misconception that writing lengthy posts conveys a lot to clients….

  33. help but buy from you. good content…

    writing services know how to produce writing in whatever format you need that will show off your Titanic expertise, so that people come to you for advice – and to buy. content writing services certainly provide a valuable service, in that they…

  34. a traditional web site. a standard blog…

    will have a list of posts with the most current post at the top, and the rest below or included in the archive. but if you want some information always readily available then adding in additional pages is the way to…

  35. is when another site was kind enough…

    to link to you on a blog posts. it is always good to link to another site and have them add a link to a post or your site as well. you can generate a lot of traffic this way as…

  36. this you would not have to know…

    about making blogs, it would be waste of precious moneymaking time. all you have to do is make a link with any of those free sites and you can start rolling in the money.now once you have setup your blog, the…

  37. be your friend forever. irony and mild…

    sarcasm are always well received; however, you still want to make sure that humor is the vehicle you are using to carry your message across to your readers.be inspirationalfind something that is uplifting and motivating for your audience. it’s easy to…

  38. Rihanna says:

    exposure to your site through those kids…

    could be good for you.)or perhaps you own a shoe store. blog posts which highlight walking and hiking paths in your area would be a good idea. a winery could keep a travelogue about day trips in the region. a pet…

  39. youtube videos, email your list, share it…

    on social networks and buy solo-ads.if you don’t promote your blog, how on earth are people going to know about it?there are many more techniques to generate traffic to your blog but these 3 are the essential ones. a blog definitely…

  40. greita says:

    and can be helpful for your customers….

    third, you will need to register with each of the forums. fourth, you have to log in to your profile and find a search table. fifth, you have to enter each of 10 topics separately into search table. then you will…

  41. Airsoft says:

    Evike.com…

    Check out our very latest own-branded Evike Airsoft range, offering amazing value on loads of Airsoft products….

  42. [...] at all unreasonable when questions started popping up about whether the Dodger catching situation would be among the worst in baseball. After all, if Ellis failed, the backup plan was… Matt Treanor? Tim Federowicz? I think [...]